Bug 881653

Summary:	media-gfx/freecad (and dependencies): arm64 keywording
Product:	Gentoo Linux	Reporter:	Niklaus 'vimja' Hofer <gentoo-bugzilla>
Component:	Keywording	Assignee:	Paul Zander <negril.nx+gentoo>
Status:	IN_PROGRESS ---
Severity:	minor	CC:	aballier, arm64, fordfrog, gentoo-bugzilla, kripton, leonchik1976, luke-jr+gentoobugs, nowa, proxy-maint, reavertm, tamiko, waebbl-gentoo
Priority:	Normal	Keywords:	CC-ARCHES, KEYWORDREQ, PullRequest
Version:	unspecified	Flags:	nattka: sanity-check-
Hardware:	ARM64
OS:	Linux
See Also:	https://github.com/gentoo/gentoo/pull/28351 https://github.com/gentoo/gentoo/pull/28768
Whiteboard:
Package list:	sci-libs/med ~arm64 media-libs/quarter ~arm64 dev-python/pivy ~arm64 media-gfx/freecad ~arm64 media-libs/SoQt ~arm64 sci-libs/pcl ~arm64 media-gfx/openscad ~arm64 media-gfx/netgen ~arm64 sci-libs/ondselsolver ~arm64	Runtime testing required:	---
Bug Depends on:	780666, 930059
Bug Blocks:

Description Niklaus 'vimja' Hofer 2022-11-17 13:48:07 UTC

I have successfully built and run media-gfx/freecad on arm64, specifically version 0.20.1. I think the ebuild should support arm64 officially.

Note however, that for that purpose, I had to build OpenNI2 from an alternative source that includes patches for arm64. Basically I used the same source as is used on Debian. I have opened a bug on that here: https://bugs.gentoo.org/780666

Here is the list of rules I added to accept_keywords:
sci-libs/med **
media-libs/quarter **
sci-libs/orocos_kdl **
dev-python/pivy **
media-gfx/freecad **


Reproducible: Always

Steps to Reproduce:
1. Add ** keyword (see above)
2. emerge www-apps/hugo
3. Run hugo

Actual Results:  
It works!

Expected Results:  
It works!

Comment 1 NATTkA bot gentoo-dev

2022-11-17 13:56:15 UTC Comment hidden (obsolete)

Sanity check failed:

> dev-python/pivy-0.6.8
>   bdepend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (12 total)
>     >=media-libs/SoQt-1.6.0
>   bdepend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (2 total)
>     >=media-libs/SoQt-1.6.0
>   depend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (12 total)
>     >=media-libs/SoQt-1.6.0
>   depend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (2 total)
>     >=media-libs/SoQt-1.6.0
>   rdepend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (12 total)
>     >=media-libs/SoQt-1.6.0
>   rdepend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (2 total)
>     >=media-libs/SoQt-1.6.0
> media-gfx/freecad-0.20.1
>   depend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (12 total)
>     >=sci-libs/pcl-1.8.1:=[opengl,openni2,qt5,vtk]
>   depend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (1 total)
>     >=sci-libs/pcl-1.8.1:=[opengl,openni2,qt5,vtk]
>   rdepend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (12 total)
>     >=sci-libs/pcl-1.8.1:=[opengl,openni2,qt5,vtk]
>   rdepend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (1 total)
>     >=sci-libs/pcl-1.8.1:=[opengl,openni2,qt5,vtk]

Comment 2 Bernd 2022-11-18 10:02:15 UTC

I like the idea, although I'm not having a arm64 based machine. I think it should be doable, as upstream officially supports OSX builds and I remember some posts about building on the new arm64 based Apple architectures (M 1?) on their forums.

If there are no objections from the arm64 arch team, I'd say let's give it a try.

Comment 3 NATTkA bot gentoo-dev

2022-11-18 10:04:15 UTC Comment hidden (obsolete)

Sanity check failed:

> sci-libs/pcl-1.12.1-r2
>   depend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (12 total)
>     dev-libs/OpenNI
>   depend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (2 total)
>     dev-libs/OpenNI
>   rdepend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (12 total)
>     dev-libs/OpenNI
>   rdepend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (2 total)
>     dev-libs/OpenNI

Comment 4 NATTkA bot gentoo-dev

2022-11-18 10:16:15 UTC Comment hidden (obsolete)

All sanity-check issues have been resolved

Comment 5 Bernd 2022-11-18 11:35:31 UTC

CC maintainers of dependent packages

Comment 6 Niklaus 'vimja' Hofer 2022-11-18 16:04:54 UTC

In the "steps to reproduce" section, of course, it should not say "www-apps/hugo" but "media-gfx/freecad". Copy & paste error. Sorry about that.

Comment 7 Roy Bamford gentoo-dev

2022-11-19 11:57:30 UTC

Portage won't let me build both dev-libs/OpenNI2 and dev-libs/OpenNI, so I've opted for dev-libs/OpenNI2. 

Meanwhile I've found bug 881995 so  media-gfx/openscad won't build for me.

Comment 8 Bernd 2022-11-19 12:07:59 UTC

(In reply to Roy Bamford from comment #7)
> Portage won't let me build both dev-libs/OpenNI2 and dev-libs/OpenNI, so
> I've opted for dev-libs/OpenNI2. 

sci-libs/pcl has USE flags for openni2 and openni, but AFAIR they can't be used together. To be able to successfully keyword pcl, I think we still need to keyword both packages.

Comment 9 Roy Bamford gentoo-dev

2022-11-19 19:01:43 UTC

There are two patches in my devspace at  https://dev.gentoo.org/~neddyseagoon/OpenNI2/ that apply to dev-libs/OpenNI2-2.2_beta2-r1 and let it build an arm64.

Its the head commit from aarch64-and-ppc-develop with one hunk removed and recreated separately because the code had been refactored.

They apply from /etc/portage/patches/dev-libs/OpenNI2/ for me.

Oh, I'm not an ebuild qualified dev. Only a forums admin.

Comment 10 Roy Bamford gentoo-dev

2022-11-19 20:47:33 UTC

(In reply to Bernd from comment #8)
> (In reply to Roy Bamford from comment #7)
> > Portage won't let me build both dev-libs/OpenNI2 and dev-libs/OpenNI, so
> > I've opted for dev-libs/OpenNI2. 
> 
> sci-libs/pcl has USE flags for openni2 and openni, but AFAIR they can't be
> used together. To be able to successfully keyword pcl, I think we still need
> to keyword both packages.

dev-libs/OpenNI2 needs patches to build on arm64.
sci-libs/pcl will need a package.use.mask on openni, so that it cannot be selected.
media-gfx/freecad will need a package.use.mask on openscad see comment 7.

All this means that media-gfx/freecad looks promising for ~arm64.

Comment 11 Roy Bamford gentoo-dev

2022-11-22 21:17:55 UTC

With bug 881995 fixed, the PR needs to be updated.
I should get to that by the weekend.

Comment 12 Bernd 2022-12-17 01:52:21 UTC

*** Bug 886101 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

Comment 13 Bernd 2022-12-18 01:23:00 UTC

*** Bug 886101 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

Comment 14 Roy Bamford gentoo-dev

2022-12-22 21:53:27 UTC

Its now PR 28768

Comment 15 NATTkA bot gentoo-dev

2023-02-23 11:28:43 UTC Comment hidden (obsolete)

Sanity check failed:

> media-gfx/freecad-0.20.2-r1
>   depend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (12 total)
>     media-gfx/netgen[opencascade]
>   depend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (1 total)
>     media-gfx/netgen[opencascade]
>   rdepend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (12 total)
>     media-gfx/netgen[opencascade]
>   rdepend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (1 total)
>     media-gfx/netgen[opencascade]

Comment 16 NATTkA bot gentoo-dev

2023-02-23 11:36:27 UTC Comment hidden (obsolete)

All sanity-check issues have been resolved

Comment 17 NATTkA bot gentoo-dev

2024-03-09 10:20:49 UTC Comment hidden (obsolete)

Sanity check failed:

> media-gfx/freecad-0.21.2-r2
>   depend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (8 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]
>   depend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (2 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]
>   rdepend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (8 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]
>   rdepend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (2 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]

Comment 18 NATTkA bot gentoo-dev

2024-03-21 23:44:42 UTC Comment hidden (obsolete)

Sanity check failed:

> media-gfx/freecad-0.21.2-r2
>   depend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (9 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]
>   depend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (2 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]
>   rdepend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (9 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]
>   rdepend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (2 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]

Comment 19 NATTkA bot gentoo-dev

2024-03-22 23:52:43 UTC Comment hidden (obsolete)

Sanity check failed:

> media-gfx/freecad-0.21.2-r2
>   depend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/23.0 (12 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]
>   depend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/23.0/hardened (10 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]
>   rdepend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/23.0 (12 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]
>   rdepend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/23.0/hardened (10 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]

Comment 20 NATTkA bot gentoo-dev

2024-04-10 14:20:55 UTC Comment hidden (obsolete)

Sanity check failed:

> media-gfx/freecad-0.21.2-r2
>   depend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (20 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]
>   depend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (12 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]
>   rdepend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/17.0 (20 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]
>   rdepend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/17.0/hardened/selinux (12 total)
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_10(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/pyside6[gui,python_targets_python3_11(-),svg,webchannel,webengine]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>     dev-python/shiboken6[python_targets_python3_11(-)]

Comment 21 NATTkA bot gentoo-dev

2024-04-15 11:56:29 UTC Comment hidden (obsolete)

All sanity-check issues have been resolved

Comment 22 NATTkA bot gentoo-dev

2025-01-23 21:35:15 UTC Comment hidden (obsolete)

Sanity check failed:

> media-gfx/freecad-1.0.0-r3
>   depend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/23.0 (12 total)
>     sci-libs/ondselsolver
>   depend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/23.0/hardened (11 total)
>     sci-libs/ondselsolver
>   rdepend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/23.0 (12 total)
>     sci-libs/ondselsolver
>   rdepend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/23.0/hardened (11 total)
>     sci-libs/ondselsolver

Comment 23 NATTkA bot gentoo-dev

2025-01-24 08:30:53 UTC Comment hidden (obsolete)

All sanity-check issues have been resolved

Comment 24 Niklaus 'vimja' Hofer 2025-02-02 15:08:30 UTC

With OpenNI2 gone from the dependencies, I think it's about time to add the ~arm64 keyword. I've been using FreeCAD on arm64 for years now. Really the only difficult bit I've ever had was with OPenNI2. Other than that installation / compilation has been going smoothly and the software runs just fine.

Comment 25 NATTkA bot gentoo-dev

2025-02-02 15:12:36 UTC Comment hidden (obsolete)

Sanity check failed:

> sci-libs/pcl-1.14.1-r2
>   depend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/23.0 (12 total)
>     dev-libs/OpenNI
>     dev-libs/OpenNI2
>   depend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/23.0/hardened (11 total)
>     dev-libs/OpenNI
>     dev-libs/OpenNI2
>   rdepend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/23.0 (12 total)
>     dev-libs/OpenNI
>     dev-libs/OpenNI2
>   rdepend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/23.0/hardened (11 total)
>     dev-libs/OpenNI
>     dev-libs/OpenNI2

Comment 26 NATTkA bot gentoo-dev

2025-04-23 14:08:52 UTC

Sanity check failed:

> sci-libs/pcl-1.14.1-r2
>   depend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/23.0 (12 total)
>     dev-libs/OpenNI
>     dev-libs/OpenNI2
>   depend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/23.0/hardened (11 total)
>     dev-libs/OpenNI
>     dev-libs/OpenNI2
>   rdepend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/23.0 (12 total)
>     dev-libs/OpenNI
>     dev-libs/OpenNI2
>   rdepend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/23.0/hardened (11 total)
>     dev-libs/OpenNI
>     dev-libs/OpenNI2
> media-gfx/freecad-1.0.0-r3
>   depend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/23.0 (12 total)
>     >=dev-python/pivy-0.6.5[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>   depend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/23.0/hardened (11 total)
>     >=dev-python/pivy-0.6.5[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>   rdepend ~arm64 stable profile default/linux/arm64/23.0 (12 total)
>     >=dev-python/pivy-0.6.5[python_targets_python3_10(-)]
>   rdepend ~arm64 dev profile default/linux/arm64/23.0/hardened (11 total)
>     >=dev-python/pivy-0.6.5[python_targets_python3_10(-)]