subtitle2pgm and other subtitle-conversion tools have been splitted from current stable transcode ebuild (0.6.14-r2) and put into an independent ebuild, subtitleripper (still keyword masked). current stable dvdrip ebuild (0.52.0) needs transcode (and correctly depends on it) AND those subtitle tools in order for its subtitle functions to work. new (but still masked) dvdrip ebuilds have a "subtitle" flag which, if used, cause subtitleripper ebuild to be emerged; I guess this "subtitle" use flag is not included in current dvdrip stable ebuild (0.52.0) because there's still no stable subtitleripper ebuild, but I guess a dvdrip-0.52.0-r1 ebuild could be done and soon marked stable, since the only change from current stable (0.52.0) would be a warning message like "dvdrip needs subtitleripper to be merged in order for some of its subtitle features to work. If you plan to use this feature you can do 'ACCEPT_KEYWORDS="~x86 emerge subtitleripper'" ...or something like that... bye Reproducible: Always Steps to Reproduce: 1. do "emerge dvdrip" 2. run dvdrip, 3. make a "new project" from "file" menu 4. open the "subtitles" tab, you see "subtitle2pgm is missing or too old" Actual Results: no subtitle ripping and conversion features available Expected Results: subtitle ripping and conversion features should be available :)
(In reply to comment #0) ...the title for this bug would maybe better be "there should be a new dvdrip 0.52.0 stable ebuild (dvdrip-0.52.0-r1) that should warn about the possibility to emerge subtitleripper with ACCEPT_KEYWORDS='~x86'" :)
I think it is more sane to mark subtitleripper as stable and a required dependency. From my observations, subtitleripper is workable (don't know if it is stable, just used it for ripping the Matrix 2 with subtitles, no errors or issues whatsoever, which is too little to call it "stable") and bugfree for quite some time... apart from 97355 which I need to verify since pgm2txt seems to work fine and I don't have gocr installed.
Ah never mind, I do have gocr installed :/
*** Bug 109372 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
Please add the depend and mark subtitleripper stable... the stable version of dvdrip shouldn't be throwing an error when a user tries to rip subtitles, which is what happens at the moment.
this should work fine on current stable ppc/amd64 archs, once x86 follows suit we get a better dvdrip there too, the x86 stabeling is a bit more involved,but we are getting there
then this is done
that was the wrong comment for this bug, sorry :) i meant the stabelization bug, since 0.52.7-r1 is now stable and depends on subtitleripper this can be closed, so that was not a mistake, just the comment as is wouldn't make much sense on this bug
