Gentoo Websites Logo
Go to: Gentoo Home Documentation Forums Lists Bugs Planet Store Wiki Get Gentoo!
Bug 251427 - sys-apps/grep-2.5.3-r1: -i is broken on OSX
Summary: sys-apps/grep-2.5.3-r1: -i is broken on OSX
Status: RESOLVED FIXED
Alias: None
Product: Gentoo/Alt
Classification: Unclassified
Component: Mac OSX (show other bugs)
Hardware: All OS X
: Low major (vote)
Assignee: Gentoo Prefix
URL: http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/bug...
Whiteboard:
Keywords:
Depends on:
Blocks:
 
Reported: 2008-12-18 09:51 UTC by Elias Pipping
Modified: 2008-12-21 16:52 UTC (History)
0 users

See Also:
Package list:
Runtime testing required: ---

Attachments
"fix" (grep-2.5.3.patch,558 bytes, patch)
2008-12-21 15:49 UTC, Elias Pipping 		Details | Diff
View All Add an attachment (proposed patch, testcase, etc.)

Note You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.
Description Elias Pipping 2008-12-18 09:51:42 UTC 
pipping@quicksand ~ $ echo F | grep F
F
pipping@quicksand ~ $ echo F | grep -i F
pipping@quicksand ~ $
Comment 1 Elias Pipping 2008-12-18 09:52:38 UTC 
The problem only manifests with capital letters

pipping@quicksand ~ $ echo nsobject | grep -i NSObject
nsobject
pipping@quicksand ~ $ echo NSobject | grep -i NSObject
pipping@quicksand ~ $
Comment 2 Elias Pipping 2008-12-18 10:00:55 UTC 
I think we need to care more about tests in prefix. The test suite tells us that it's broken.

Testing:  ../src/grep Word -o -i
  input:  "WordA/wordB/WORDC/"
  output: ""
  expect: "Word/word/WORD/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep WORD -o -i
  input:  "WordA/wordB/WORDC/"
  output: ""
  expect: "Word/word/WORD/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep w. -o -b
  input:  "XwA YwB/ZwC/"
  output: "4:wA/8:wB/12:wC/"
  expect: "1:wA/5:wB/9:wC/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep w. -o -b -i
  input:  "XwA YwB/ZwC/"
  output: "4:wA/8:wB/12:wC/"
  expect: "1:wA/5:wB/9:wC/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep w. -o -b -3
  input:  "XwA YwB/ZwC/"
  output: "4:wA/8:wB/12:wC/"
  expect: "1:wA/5:wB/9:wC/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep w -F -o -b
  input:  "XwA YwB/ZwC/"
  output: "4:w/8:w/12:w/"
  expect: "1:w/5:w/9:w/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep w -F -o -b -i
  input:  "XwA YwB/ZwC/"
  output: "4:w/8:w/12:w/"
  expect: "1:w/5:w/9:w/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep w -F -o -b -3
  input:  "XwA YwB/ZwC/"
  output: "4:w/8:w/12:w/"
  expect: "1:w/5:w/9:w/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep ^word_* -o
  input:  "word_word/"
  output: ""
  expect: "word_/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep Word --color=always -i
  input:  "WordA/wordb/WORDC/"
  output: "-n WordA/wordb/WORDC/"
  expect: "[01;31m[KWord[m[KA/[01;31m[Kword[m[Kb/[01;31m[KWORD[m[KC/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep word --color=always -i
  input:  "WordA/wordb/WORDC/"
  output: "-n [01;31m[KWord[m[KA/[01;31m[Kword[m[Kb/[01;31m[KWORD[m[KC/"
  expect: "[01;31m[KWord[m[KA/[01;31m[Kword[m[Kb/[01;31m[KWORD[m[KC/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep WORD --color=always -i
  input:  "WordA/wordb/WORDC/"
  output: "-n WordA/wordb/WORDC/"
  expect: "[01;31m[KWord[m[KA/[01;31m[Kword[m[Kb/[01;31m[KWORD[m[KC/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep ^word_* --color=always
  input:  "word_word/"
  output: ""
  expect: "[01;31m[Kword_[m[Kword/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep \<word --color=always
  input:  "wordword/"
  output: "-n [01;31m[Kword[m[Kword/"
  expect: "[01;31m[Kword[m[Kword/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep ^4$ -m1 -A99
  input:  "4/40/"
  output: ""
  expect: "4/40/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep ^4$ -m1 -A99
  input:  "4/04/"
  output: ""
  expect: "4/04/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep ^4$ -m1 -A99
  input:  "4/444/"
  output: ""
  expect: "4/444/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep ^4 -m1 -A99
  input:  "4/40/"
  output: "40//"
  expect: "4/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep ^4 -m1 -A99
  input:  "4/04/"
  output: ""
  expect: "4/04/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep ^4 -m1 -A99
  input:  "4/444/"
  output: "444//"
  expect: "4/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep 4$ -m1 -A99
  input:  "4/40/"
  output: "-n 4/40//"
  expect: "4/40/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep 4$ -m1 -A99
  input:  "4/04/"
  output: "-n 4/"
  expect: "4/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep 4$ -m1 -A99
  input:  "4/444/"
  output: "-n 4/"
  expect: "4/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -wF -e A -e B -e C
  input:  "A/CX/B/C/"
  output: "-n A/B/C/"
  expect: "A/B/C/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep --color=always y*
  input:  "xyz/"
  output: "-n x[01;31m[Ky[m[Kz//"
  expect: "x[01;31m[Ky[m[Kz/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -E --color=always -e bb -e cc -e ccc
  input:  "a bb ccc dddd/"
  output: "-n a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
  expect: "a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -F --color=always -e bb -e cc -e ccc
  input:  "a bb ccc dddd/"
  output: "-n a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
  expect: "a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -E --color=always -e bb -e ccc -e cc
  input:  "a bb ccc dddd/"
  output: "-n a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
  expect: "a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -F --color=always -e bb -e ccc -e cc
  input:  "a bb ccc dddd/"
  output: "-n a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
  expect: "a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -E -w --color=always -e bb -e ccc
  input:  "a bb ccc dddd/"
  output: "-n a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
  expect: "a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -F -w --color=always -e bb -e ccc
  input:  "a bb ccc dddd/"
  output: "-n a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
  expect: "a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -E -w --color=always -e ccc -e bb
  input:  "a bb ccc dddd/"
  output: "-n a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
  expect: "a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -F -w --color=always -e ccc -e bb
  input:  "a bb ccc dddd/"
  output: "-n a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
  expect: "a [01;31m[Kbb[m[K [01;31m[Kccc[m[K dddd/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -E -w --color=always -e bb -e ccc
  input:  "dddd ccc bb a/"
  output: "-n dddd [01;31m[Kccc[m[K [01;31m[Kbb[m[K a/"
  expect: "dddd [01;31m[Kccc[m[K [01;31m[Kbb[m[K a/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -F -w --color=always -e bb -e ccc
  input:  "dddd ccc bb a/"
  output: "-n dddd [01;31m[Kccc[m[K [01;31m[Kbb[m[K a/"
  expect: "dddd [01;31m[Kccc[m[K [01;31m[Kbb[m[K a/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -E -w --color=always -e ccc -e bb
  input:  "dddd ccc bb a/"
  output: "-n dddd [01;31m[Kccc[m[K [01;31m[Kbb[m[K a/"
  expect: "dddd [01;31m[Kccc[m[K [01;31m[Kbb[m[K a/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -F -w --color=always -e ccc -e bb
  input:  "dddd ccc bb a/"
  output: "-n dddd [01;31m[Kccc[m[K [01;31m[Kbb[m[K a/"
  expect: "dddd [01;31m[Kccc[m[K [01;31m[Kbb[m[K a/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -E -w --color=always bc
  input:  "bcd abcd abc bc bcd abc/"
  output: "-n bcd abcd abc [01;31m[Kbc[m[K bcd abc/"
  expect: "bcd abcd abc [01;31m[Kbc[m[K bcd abc/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -F -w --color=always bc
  input:  "bcd abcd abc bc bcd abc/"
  output: "-n bcd abcd abc [01;31m[Kbc[m[K bcd abc/"
  expect: "bcd abcd abc [01;31m[Kbc[m[K bcd abc/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -E -w --color=always bc
  input:  "bc abcd bc/"
  output: "-n [01;31m[Kbc[m[K abcd [01;31m[Kbc[m[K/"
  expect: "[01;31m[Kbc[m[K abcd [01;31m[Kbc[m[K/"
FAIL
Testing:  ../src/grep -F -w --color=always bc
  input:  "bc abcd bc/"
  output: "-n [01;31m[Kbc[m[K abcd [01;31m[Kbc[m[K/"
  expect: "[01;31m[Kbc[m[K abcd [01;31m[Kbc[m[K/"
FAIL
FAIL: foad1.sh
Comment 3 Elias Pipping 2008-12-18 10:05:48 UTC 
the bug still exists in their CVS
Comment 4 Jeremy Olexa (darkside) (RETIRED) archtester gentoo-dev Security 2008-12-18 16:39:18 UTC 
FYI:
OSX only problem. Automated testsuite (expect other locales, i probably don't have that setup right) and manual testing pass on Linux.
Comment 6 Fabian Groffen gentoo-dev 2008-12-18 20:45:13 UTC 
do you suggest we mask?  (I found it annoyingly locks up Terminal.app as well with its colours)
Comment 7 Elias Pipping 2008-12-18 20:48:50 UTC 
well iirc 2.5.1 and 2.5.1 were at least as broken so there's nothing we can do about it.
Comment 8 Elias Pipping 2008-12-21 15:49:18 UTC 
Created attachment 176053 [details, diff]
"fix"
Comment 9 Fabian Groffen gentoo-dev 2008-12-21 16:52:40 UTC 
applied, thanks