I'd like to request stable marking of twisted-8.1.0 (and -web, -words, probably others). I know it fails in src_test, but that's no regression, old versions also do. python-team, please comment on it and cc archs if you're ok with that.
archs please go ahead
Sparc done for twisted{-words,-web}-8.1.0 --- I'll leave us on CC in case you add to the list of requested packages.
Stable for HPPA.
ppc64 stable
alpha/ia64/x86 stable
@Python: What about -mail, -names, -news, -lore and -runner?
Yeah, this is a problem. twisted-mail's stable version 0.3.0 is now only available for use with twisted-2.4.0, and recent buildbot seems to require twisted-mail, so all buildbot users cannot upgrade at this point. Please fix this.
dev-python/twisted-8.1.0 generates the following error during the first merge: ============================ * Byte compiling python modules for python-2.5 .. ... [ ok ] * Regenerating plugin cache Traceback (most recent call last): File "<string>", line 1, in <module> File "/usr/lib/python2.5/site-packages/twisted/plugin.py", line 200, in getPlugins allDropins = getCache(package) --- <exception caught here> --- File "/usr/lib/python2.5/site-packages/twisted/plugin.py", line 165, in getCache provider = pluginModule.load() File "/usr/lib/python2.5/site-packages/twisted/python/modules.py", line 380, in load return self.pathEntry.pythonPath.moduleLoader(self.name) File "/usr/lib/python2.5/site-packages/twisted/python/modules.py", line 618, in moduleLoader return self._moduleLoader(modname) File "/usr/lib/python2.5/site-packages/twisted/python/reflect.py", line 426, in namedAny topLevelPackage = _importAndCheckStack(trialname) File "/usr/lib/python2.5/site-packages/twisted/plugins/testplugin.py", line 12, in <module> from twisted.plugin import IPlugin, ITestPlugin, ITestPlugin2 exceptions.ImportError: cannot import name ITestPlugin ================================ After the error, the installation is actually successful, but I'm not sure it's trustworthy. Merging a second time resolves the problem (I assume because ITestPlugin is now available - I didn't actually look).
And yes, the stable tree is broken. If you have any dependency on twisted-names, which has a dep on "=dev-python/twisted-2.4*", then portage will try to pull in both dev-python/twisted-2.4.0 and dev-python/twisted-8.1.0, which are in the same slot, so produce a conflict.
Sorry, I meant to point out that the current stable twisted-names, dev-python/twisted-names-0.3.0, has that "=dev-python/twisted-2.4*" dependency.
For the test failures, this is known, though it also appears in the current stable ones, so it's not a regression. Beside -web and -words, the following have hard deps on 2.4, so should probably be stable marked in sync: -xish -runner -pair -news -names -mail -lore -flow -conch
After some testing, it seems to me that these are ready to go stable: twisted-8.1.0 twisted-web-8.1.0 twisted-words-8.1.0 twisted-conch-8.1.0 twisted-lore-8.1.0 twisted-mail-8.1.0 twisted-names-8.1.0 twisted-news-8.1.0 twisted-runner-8.0.0 And these packages should be removed from the tree: twisted-xish twisted-pair twisted-flow as well as twibber and old versions of pymsn-t which depend on twisted-xish.
old pymsn-t removed
Sparc stable also for: twisted-runner-8.0.0 twisted-names-8.1.0 twisted-conch-8.1.0 twisted-mail-8.1.0 twisted-news-8.1.0 twisted-conch-8.1.0 (All tests pass, although runner/names/news don't seem to have any tests.) Keeping sparc on CC in case more requirements emerge.
Hello, dev-python/twisted-xish dev-python/twisted-pair dev-python/twisted-flow dev-python/twibber Are now masked for removal in 30 days. as Coldwind pointed out, they are of no use now. Please, go ahead with stabilization. Thanks,
Old versions of twisted-words (twisted-words-0.1.0-r1.ebuild and twisted-words-0.1.0-r2.ebuild) are removed from tree as they also depended on dev-python/twisted-xish Regards,
amd64 stable. repoman warnings: dev-python/twisted-web/twisted-web-8.1.0.ebuild: IUSE is not defined dev-python/twisted-names/twisted-names-8.1.0.ebuild: IUSE is not defined dev-python/twisted-conch/twisted-conch-8.1.0.ebuild: IUSE is not defined dev-python/twisted-mail/twisted-mail-8.1.0.ebuild: IUSE is not defined dev-python/twisted-lore/twisted-lore-8.1.0.ebuild: IUSE is not defined dev-python/twisted-news/twisted-news-8.1.0.ebuild: IUSE is not defined dev-python/twisted-runner/twisted-runner-8.0.0.ebuild: IUSE is not defined IUSE is set in twisted.eclass, but you should define it in the ebuild too, even if it's empty.
Marking something stable requires that all stable ebuilds work with the most recent stable common dependency you're stabilizing. This has been botched in this case, as comment 7 and bug 234765 highlight. cc'ing the QA team, since this should not happen in the stable tree. I wonder what is so hard about to understand that this is not acceptable, given that I see such issues a lot more often nowadays.
Please, hppa and ppc64, stabilize ASAP since you still have broken stable tree. The rest of arches are ok.
(In reply to comment #20) > Please, hppa and ppc64, stabilize ASAP since you still have broken stable tree. Stabilise what?
(In reply to comment #21) > > Stabilise what? > See comment #12. Anything in that list if you have previous stable versions.
Nothing to do.
ppc stable
All seems done
