celestia.desktop file has the following category: Categories=Science;Astronomy;GTK This causes celestia menu entry be shown in Others menu when it should be shown in Education It should be: Categories=Education;Science;Astronomy;GTK This was already fixed in 1.4.2, but seems that updated patch for 1.5.0 doesn't use proper Category Thanks Reproducible: Always
Hi Pacho, Thanks for reporting. All sci-* ebuilds where we use the make_desktop_entry from the eutils eclass do not set Education in the Categories field, so I chose to follow the same rule. I am not sure what to do actually. XFCE uses the secondary category Science and the desktop entry appears properly in Science and KDE too. Doesn't Gnome do this? Basically to keep consistency we should check all sci-* ebuilds and the eutils eclass to consistently set either Education or Science in the desktop entry.
(In reply to comment #1) > Hi Pacho, > > Thanks for reporting. All sci-* ebuilds where we use the make_desktop_entry > from the eutils eclass do not set Education in the Categories field, so I chose > to follow the same rule. But this is also a bug: http://bugs.gentoo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=191000 > > I am not sure what to do actually. XFCE uses the secondary category Science and > the desktop entry appears properly in Science and KDE too. Doesn't Gnome do > this? > Gnome doesn't have Science menu category, also in: http://standards.freedesktop.org/menu-spec/latest/apa.html "Science" is not a main category Thanks :-)
Education fixed as the main category in cvs. Thanks.
