gmane.linux.gentoo.council is accessible, whereas on archives.gentoo.org I cannot find the gentoo-council mailing list archives. Another point for archives.gentoo.org is that I canot read the mail from a few minutes or hours ago - it seems to be old, can that be fixed, please? Oh and maybe it is possible to make that available as a news server similar to gmane because for example in gmane I cannot post to gentoo.council and I dont like to fire up my email client for such a thing.
I think this got missed because we used the determination that if a list wasn't able to be subscribed publically, it shouldn't be on the archives site. I guess we could audit the ones like that and ask the devs which ones they would like added. This one would definately be the case if its been included on gmane. Could someone please verify with the council before we add this? Thanks-
Just a ping on this confirmation? Should I go ahead and add council to the list of online archives? The site was temporarily behind due to some debugging. It updates hourly normally.
nice to see some action. No idea if ramereth actually asked them for confirmation. Anyway do you want to ask the old or the new council? ;) But it is listed in gmane and public to everyone - also listed in http://www.gentoo.org/main/en/lists.xml I wonder why it has not ben added in the first place.
ping? you can just WONTFIX it if you dont want to fix it.
funny, I didn't even know we had a mailing list for council. As the council guy, I don't think we mind it being archived considering it's already archived on gmane. give the other council guys a day or 2 to speak up, otherwise do it. Regarding the speed problems, is it still an issue?
yes, gentoo-council should be available on the public archives
I wasn't aware that we had a council list, either.
I knew about it just incidentally, it hasn't been used in a long time for what I can see, I wonder if we really need it, but archiving it is good to me.
Archiving it would definitely be a good idea and we might want to consider cross posting reminders and meetinglogs to it.
I've added gentoo-council to the lists being archived. The speed issues were temporary, the site wasn't being repopulated regularly to allow for debugging on the version that was live at the time.
Turns out that gentoo-council hasn't actually been setup to forward to the archive s user on nuthatch. So while it was in my list of private mailing lists, there's nothing for the archives site to display. To get this setup on archives.gentoo.org, I would need some assistance to see if we have a copy of the old posts in maildir format, and forwarding if it will be getting any new posts.
(In reply to comment #11) > Turns out that gentoo-council hasn't actually been setup to forward to the > archive s user on nuthatch. So while it was in my list of private mailing > lists, there's nothing for the archives site to display. > > To get this setup on archives.gentoo.org, I would need some assistance to see > if we have a copy of the old posts in maildir format, and forwarding if it will > be getting any new posts. > sounds like a job for lcars?
ping - what is up here? Seems lcars has no interest in helping. Maybe we can just drop the gentoo-council mailing list if it is that hard to archive it - it is not used anyway these days. or just leave status quo - gmane is not down that often. Thus we do not need to use gentoo infra to provide a mostly dead mailing list. INVALID or CANTFIX seem to be fitting resolutions - choose as you wish :)
(In reply to comment #13) > ping - what is up here? Seems lcars has no interest in helping. > > Maybe we can just drop the gentoo-council mailing list if it is that hard to > archive it - it is not used anyway these days. > > or just leave status quo - gmane is not down that often. Thus we do not need to > use gentoo infra to provide a mostly dead mailing list. > > INVALID or CANTFIX seem to be fitting resolutions - choose as you wish :) > Stop being an ass please. It might not see any heavy list traffic but we still want it archived on our own infra.
new mail does go to the list, will repopulate with old mail later.
