Following discussion in gentoo-dev: <http://archives.gentoo.org/gentoo-dev/msg_e4e4974dcb53f9fc606cbe95f172f9c8.xml> Both "audio" and "sounds" local USE flags should be renamed to "sound" (which is a global flag now). Affected packages: games: games-action/abuse games-rpg/drascula games-strategy/heroes3 media-libs/libsdl pva: net-p2p/eiskaltdcpp volkmar, voip: net-libs/opal net-libs/ptlib
Ulrich, please, CC all maintainers next time :) net-p2p/eiskaltdcpp done.
Oh, reopen, since only there are other packages left...
I did the change to games-action/abuse games-rpg/drascula To apply the change to media-libs/libsdl we should also take care of the ebuilds that depends on libsdl[audio] media-tv/xbmc media-sound/freewheeling games-emulation/gngb games-emulation/virtualjaguar games-emulation/mednafen games-emulation/openmsx games-emulation/raine games-emulation/hatari games-emulation/lxdream games-emulation/generator games-board/biloba games-board/gtkboard games-kids/pytraffic games-action/towbowl-tactics games-action/teeworlds games-action/extreme-tuxracer games-action/maelstrom games-action/supertuxkart games-action/gltron games-action/trackballs games-action/violetland games-action/d1x-rebirth games-action/d2x games-action/bzflag games-rpg/adonthell games-rpg/daimonin-client games-roguelike/angband games-engines/exult games-engines/qtads games-engines/stratagus games-strategy/naev games-strategy/boswars games-strategy/freecnc games-strategy/lgeneral games-strategy/hedgewars games-strategy/freeciv games-puzzle/einstein games-puzzle/zaz games-puzzle/rezerwar games-puzzle/gnurobbo games-puzzle/neverball games-puzzle/jag games-puzzle/brainparty games-puzzle/concentration games-puzzle/amoebax games-puzzle/wizznic games-puzzle/bubble-chains games-puzzle/cuyo games-simulation/cannonsmash games-simulation/simutrans games-simulation/lincity-ng games-simulation/openttd games-simulation/gl117 games-sports/toycars games-sports/race games-arcade/missile games-arcade/jumpnbump games-arcade/slimevolley games-arcade/tomatoes games-arcade/rockdodger games-arcade/lbreakout2 games-arcade/primateplunge games-arcade/pengupop games-arcade/sdlsasteroids games-arcade/kajaani-kombat games-arcade/amphetamine games-arcade/yarsrevenge games-fps/quake2-icculus games-fps/rott Are we sure that all that is really needed?
(In reply to comment #3) > To apply the change to media-libs/libsdl we should also take care of the > ebuilds that depends on libsdl[audio] > > [...] > > Are we sure that all that is really needed? Would be nice to have, and it's not really a problem to do these replacements with a script. (Maybe coordinate with infra, so that rsync mirrors will see an atomic change.)
Since there's no action by maintainers here, I'm going to fix the following remaining packages and their reverse dependencies: dastergon: app-misc/recoll enlightenment: dev-libs/efl games: games-strategy/heroes3 media-libs/libsdl media-libs/libsdl2 maintainer-needed: net-libs/h323plus neurogeek: net-libs/opal net-libs/ptlib
> maintainer-needed: > net-libs/h323plus > > neurogeek: > net-libs/opal > net-libs/ptlib These are fixed.
(In reply to Ulrich Müller from comment #5) > games: > games-strategy/heroes3 This one has "sounds" and "videos" flags along with a "music" flag that install optional data. I'm leaving it like this, for the time being. > media-libs/libsdl > media-libs/libsdl2 Fixed.
(In reply to Ulrich Müller from comment #5) > Since there's no action by maintainers here, Sorry, I should have worded this differently. "No action" relates only to the packages that were already listed in comment #0. Please change the "audio" flag to "sound", or raise your objections why it shouldn't be done for your package.
> enlightenment: > dev-libs/efl Fixed, as discussed with tommy.
Hi! I have encountered emerge problems now after the latest update. There are some packages left that still require the audio use flag. It would have been nice if all packages were fixed at once... Here are my problematic packages: media-tv/xbmc media-video/ffmpeg media-plugins/audacious-plugins Please fix those as well. Thank you!
(In reply to Günther Hutzl from comment #10) > It would have been nice if all packages were fixed at once... They _have_ been fixed at once, but seems that not all of libsdl's 134 reverse dependencies made it into the same time slice for propagating from CVS to rsync. Re-sync and try again.
this bug is 3 years old and you just went ahead and "fixed" things without contacting the active maintainers of e.g. libsdl2 you are aware that this simply breaks a LOT of overlays? Why has this been applied without any recent discussion?
(In reply to Julian Ospald (hasufell) from comment #12) > this bug is 3 years old and you just went ahead and "fixed" things without > contacting the active maintainers of e.g. libsdl2 > > you are aware that this simply breaks a LOT of overlays? Why has this been > applied without any recent discussion? A link to the thread in -dev is in comment #0, and the conclusion was that audio should be renamed to sound. Why should it be discussed again, if there was consensus? As for libsdl2, that package should have had IUSE="sound" (instead of "audio") from the very beginning.
(In reply to Ulrich Müller from comment #13) > (In reply to Julian Ospald (hasufell) from comment #12) > > this bug is 3 years old and you just went ahead and "fixed" things without > > contacting the active maintainers of e.g. libsdl2 > > > > you are aware that this simply breaks a LOT of overlays? Why has this been > > applied without any recent discussion? > > A link to the thread in -dev is in comment #0, and the conclusion was that > audio should be renamed to sound. Why should it be discussed again, if there > was consensus? > > As for libsdl2, that package should have had IUSE="sound" (instead of > "audio") from the very beginning. I was talking about _recent_ discussion. This is not a trivial step and there was zero communication. E.g. when I imported libsdl2 unslotted, I contacted all major game overlays beforehand. This probably just broke most of the sunrise ebuilds as well. Did any1 tell them? I guess not.
(In reply to Julian Ospald (hasufell) from comment #14) So, what do you want us to do? Should media-libs/libsdl{,2} return to IUSE="audio", i.e. should the change be reverted? If that is the goal, then please restart discussion in the gentoo-dev mailing list. Regarding "zero communication": This was discussed in gentoo-dev, and that the discussion was already some time ago doesn't invalidate it. There is this bug open since long, tagged with a QAcanfix keyword from the very beginning, and maintainers of libsdl and libsdl2 are in CC. In addition, I have announced the upcoming action again in comment #5. So this can hardly come as a surprise. Also please note that for those packages whose maintainers were added to CC only recently, I have taken no action yet (except for efl, where tommy has given his o.k. on IRC). That there is breakage for some packages in overlays is unfortunate, but responsibility for overlays is entirely with their owners. I'm not aware of any policy that would require consideration of overlays when committing to the main Portage tree.
(In reply to Ulrich Müller from comment #15) > (In reply to Julian Ospald (hasufell) from comment #14) > > So, what do you want us to do? Communicate more.
> dastergon: > app-misc/recoll Fixed, as discussed with dastergon. All done, closing.
A version bump sure would've been nice for those changed ebuilds so the overlays don't blow up. :)
