Gentoo Websites Logo
Go to: Gentoo Home Documentation Forums Lists Bugs Planet Store Wiki Get Gentoo!
Bug 103563 (alt-rootroot) - chown root:root will be ignored on many Gentoo/ALT platforms
Summary: chown root:root will be ignored on many Gentoo/ALT platforms
Status: RESOLVED FIXED
Alias: alt-rootroot
Product: Gentoo/Alt
Classification: Unclassified
Component: Other (show other bugs)
Hardware: All FreeBSD
: High minor
Assignee: Gentoo non-Linux Team
URL:
Whiteboard:
Keywords:
Depends on:
Blocks:
 
Reported: 2005-08-24 01:42 UTC by Diego Elio Pettenò (RETIRED)
Modified: 2006-04-12 10:50 UTC (History)
8 users (show)

See Also:
Package list:
Runtime testing required: ---

Attachments
Add an attachment (proposed patch, testcase, etc.)

Note You need to log in before you can comment on or make changes to this bug.
Description Diego Elio Pettenò (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-24 01:42:11 UTC 
As in summary, chown root:root will fail/be ignored on BSD and Darwin Gentoo  
systems. The reason is that 0-id group there is "wheel".  
  
The solution is simply to change the chown line to root:0 .  
As for cp -a, also if the package is linux-specific, better be nice with  
crosscompilers/crossinstaller and fix all the reasonably fixable.  
   
app-emulation/vmware-workstation/vmware-workstation-5.0.0.13124-r1.ebuild:    
chown called on root:root [vmware]    
app-forensics/air/air-1.2.7.ebuild: chown called on root:root [forensics |    
forensics@gentoo.org]    
app-misc/evidence/evidence-9999.ebuild: chown called on root:root [no-herd |    
vapier@gentoo.org]    
app-text/acroread/acroread-7.0.1.1.ebuild: chown called on root:root    
[printing]    
dev-db/firebird/firebird-1.5.2.ebuild: chown called on root:root [no-herd |    
sekretarz@gentoo.org]    
dev-embedded/gpsim-lcd/gpsim-lcd-0.2.1.ebuild: chown called on root:root    
[dev-embedded]    
dev-lang/cxx/cxx-6.5.9.31-r1.ebuild: chown called on root:root [no-herd |    
taviso@gentoo.org]    
dev-libs/libcxml/libcxml-5.2.0.ebuild: chown called on root:root [no-herd |    
taviso@gentoo.org]    
dev-lisp/cmucl-source/cmucl-source-19a.ebuild: chown called on root:root    
[common-lisp]    
dev-util/aegis/aegis-4.9.ebuild: chown called on root:root [no-herd |    
karltk@gentoo.org]    
gnustep-libs/artresources/artresources-0.1.2.ebuild: chown called on root:root    
[gnustep]    
mail-mta/courier/courier-0.50.1-r1.ebuild: chown called on root:root [no-herd    
| swtaylor@gentoo.org]    
media-gfx/qingy-themes/qingy-themes-20050816.ebuild: chown called on root:root    
[no-herd | s4t4n@gentoo.org]    
media-gfx/bootsplash-themes/bootsplash-themes-20040821-r1.ebuild: chown called    
on root:root [no-herd | spock@gentoo.org]    
net-analyzer/metasploit/metasploit-2.4-r1.ebuild: chown called on root:root    
[netmon | netmon@gentoo.org]    
net-analyzer/ntop/ntop-3.1.ebuild: chown called on root:root [netmon]    
net-mail/vpopmail/vpopmail-5.4.9-r2.ebuild: chown called on root:root    
[net-mail]    
net-misc/l7-protocols/l7-protocols-2005.08.10.ebuild: chown called on    
root:root [no-herd | dragonheart@gentoo.org]    
sci-mathematics/gimps/gimps-24.6.ebuild: chown called on root:root [no-herd |    
spock@gentoo.org]    
sci-misc/qcad-parts/qcad-parts-2.0.1.2.ebuild: chown called on root:root [sci]    
sys-apps/sal-client/sal-client-1.0_rc3.ebuild: chown called on root:root    
[base-system]    
sys-apps/man/man-1.6a.ebuild: chown called on root:root [base-system]    
sys-block/partimage/partimage-0.6.4-r4.ebuild: chown called on root:root    
[base-system | xmerlin@gentoo.org]    
www-servers/tomcat/tomcat-5.0.28-r4.ebuild: chown called on root:root [java |    
luckyduck@gentoo.org]    
www-servers/orion/orion-2.0.5.ebuild: chown called on root:root [java]    
www-servers/ncsa-httpd/ncsa-httpd-1.5.2a.ebuild: chown called on root:root    
[www-servers]    
x11-plugins/desklet-rssgrab/desklet-rssgrab-0.6.2.ebuild: chown called on    
root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org]    
x11-plugins/desklet-rhythmlet/desklet-rhythmlet-0.3g.ebuild: chown called on    
root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org]    
x11-plugins/desklet-psisensors/desklet-psisensors-20040420.ebuild: chown    
called on root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org]    
x11-plugins/desklet-weather/desklet-weather-0.25.ebuild: chown called on    
root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org]    
x11-plugins/desklet-wireless/desklet-wireless-0.2.ebuild: chown called on    
root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org]    
x11-plugins/desklet-ltvariations/desklet-ltvariations-0.26.ebuild: chown    
called on root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org]    
x11-plugins/desklet-sysinfo/desklet-sysinfo-0.25.ebuild: chown called on    
root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org]    
x11-plugins/desklet-psiextras/desklet-psiextras-0.1.ebuild: chown called on    
root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org]    
x11-plugins/desklet-calendar/desklet-calendar-0.2.5.2.ebuild: chown called on    
root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org]    
x11-plugins/desklet-temperature/desklet-temperature-0.2.ebuild: chown called    
on root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org]    
x11-plugins/desklet-cornerxmms/desklet-cornerxmms-0.0.5-r1.ebuild: chown    
called on root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org]    
x11-themes/windowmaker-themes/windowmaker-themes-0.1.ebuild: chown called on    
root:root [gnustep]    
x11-themes/iceicons/iceicons-0.10.0.ebuild: chown called on root:root    
[desktop-wm]    
x11-themes/icewm-themes/icewm-themes-0.0.1-r1.ebuild: chown called on    
root:root [desktop-wm]    
x11-themes/gdeskcal-skins/gdeskcal-skins-0.0.1.ebuild: chown called on    
root:root [desktop-misc | pclouds@gentoo.org]    
 
(This bug is considered minor as it doesn't make packages non-installable, 
rather they have broken permissions) 
 
Thanks again,  
Diego
Comment 1 Tavis Ormandy (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-24 01:57:01 UTC 
cxx/cxml are alpha-linux specific
Comment 2 Diego Elio Pettenò (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-24 01:59:00 UTC 
Forgot to add... if you want me to take care of fixing these bugs for 
your/your herd's packages, just state so and remove yourself/the herd from CC, 
and I'll do the change as stated (enewuser, cp -a and chown, it's a 
multi-comment). 
 
If it's for a herd, please say which herd you're referring to as i don't know 
them all by heart :)
Comment 3 Karol Wojtaszek (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-24 02:06:49 UTC 
dev-db/firebird done
Comment 4 Fernando J. Pereda (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-24 02:33:09 UTC 
vpopmail fixed

Cheers,
Ferdy
Comment 5 Aaron Walker (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-24 04:27:16 UTC 
www-servers/ncsa-httpd done
Comment 6 Michele Noberasco (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-24 04:31:24 UTC 
qingy-themes fixed
Comment 7 Marcus D. Hanwell (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-24 05:04:33 UTC 
sci-misc/qcad-parts fixed.
Comment 8 Diego Elio Pettenò (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-24 07:22:34 UTC 
As asked by dragonheart, I've fixed netmon, forensics, dev-embedded and his  
ebuilds.
Comment 9 Chris Gianelloni (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-24 07:54:29 UTC 
I did VMware even though it requires the Linux kernel due to needing to build
external modules.
Comment 10 Diego Elio Pettenò (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-26 05:24:03 UTC 
Remaining ebuilds: 
 
app-misc/evidence/evidence-9999.ebuild: chown called on root:root [no-herd | 
vapier@gentoo.org] 
app-text/acroread/acroread-7.0.1.1.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[printing] 
dev-lisp/cmucl-source/cmucl-source-19a.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[common-lisp] 
dev-util/aegis/aegis-4.9.ebuild: chown called on root:root [no-herd | 
karltk@gentoo.org] 
gnustep-libs/artresources/artresources-0.1.2.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[gnustep] 
mail-mta/courier/courier-0.50.1-r1.ebuild: chown called on root:root [no-herd 
| swtaylor@gentoo.org] 
media-gfx/bootsplash-themes/bootsplash-themes-20040821-r1.ebuild: chown called 
on root:root [no-herd | spock@gentoo.org] 
sci-mathematics/gimps/gimps-24.6.ebuild: chown called on root:root [no-herd | 
spock@gentoo.org] 
sys-apps/sal-client/sal-client-1.0_rc3.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[base-system] 
sys-apps/man/man-1.6a.ebuild: chown called on root:root [base-system] 
sys-block/partimage/partimage-0.6.4-r4.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[base-system | xmerlin@gentoo.org] 
www-servers/tomcat/tomcat-5.0.28-r4.ebuild: chown called on root:root [java | 
luckyduck@gentoo.org] 
www-servers/orion/orion-2.0.5.ebuild: chown called on root:root [java] 
x11-plugins/desklet-rssgrab/desklet-rssgrab-0.6.2.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org] 
x11-plugins/desklet-rhythmlet/desklet-rhythmlet-0.3g.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org] 
x11-plugins/desklet-psisensors/desklet-psisensors-20040420.ebuild: chown 
called on root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org] 
x11-plugins/desklet-weather/desklet-weather-0.25.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org] 
x11-plugins/desklet-wireless/desklet-wireless-0.2.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org] 
x11-plugins/desklet-ltvariations/desklet-ltvariations-0.26.ebuild: chown 
called on root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org] 
x11-plugins/desklet-sysinfo/desklet-sysinfo-0.25.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org] 
x11-plugins/desklet-psiextras/desklet-psiextras-0.1.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org] 
x11-plugins/desklet-calendar/desklet-calendar-0.2.5.2.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org] 
x11-plugins/desklet-temperature/desklet-temperature-0.2.ebuild: chown called 
on root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org] 
x11-plugins/desklet-cornerxmms/desklet-cornerxmms-0.0.5-r1.ebuild: chown 
called on root:root [gnome | obz@gentoo.org] 
x11-themes/windowmaker-themes/windowmaker-themes-0.1.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [gnustep] 
x11-themes/iceicons/iceicons-0.10.0.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[desktop-wm] 
x11-themes/icewm-themes/icewm-themes-0.0.1-r1.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [desktop-wm] 
x11-themes/gdeskcal-skins/gdeskcal-skins-0.0.1.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [desktop-misc | pclouds@gentoo.org] 
Affected herds: desktop-misc, base-system, java, gnome, common-lisp, 
desktop-wm, gnustep, no-herd, printing 
Affected devs: spock@gentoo.org, pclouds@gentoo.org, xmerlin@gentoo.org, 
luckyduck@gentoo.org, obz@gentoo.org, swtaylor@gentoo.org, karltk@gentoo.org, 
vapier@gentoo.org
Comment 11 Diego Elio Pettenò (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-26 06:57:51 UTC 
I've fixed java-related packages, thus removing related CCs.
Comment 12 Michal Januszewski (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-26 11:00:11 UTC 
sci-mathematics/gimps and media-gfx/bootsplash-themes fixed.
Comment 13 Joe Sapp (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-26 13:55:01 UTC 
Fixed all the desklet- ebuilds so I'm removing gdesklets (and obz) from CC list.
Comment 14 Heinrich Wendel (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-08-27 09:47:37 UTC 
printing done
Comment 15 Diego Elio Pettenò (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-09-02 04:21:42 UTC 
app-misc/evidence/evidence-9999.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[vapier@gentoo.org] 
dev-lisp/cmucl-source/cmucl-source-19a.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[common-lisp] 
dev-util/aegis/aegis-4.9.ebuild: chown called on root:root [karltk@gentoo.org] 
gnustep-libs/artresources/artresources-0.1.2.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[gnustep] 
mail-mta/courier/courier-0.50.1-r1.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[swtaylor@gentoo.org] 
sys-apps/sal-client/sal-client-1.0_rc3.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[base-system] 
sys-apps/man/man-1.6a.ebuild: chown called on root:root [base-system] 
sys-block/partimage/partimage-0.6.4-r4.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[base-system | xmerlin@gentoo.org] 
x11-themes/windowmaker-themes/windowmaker-themes-0.1.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [gnustep] 
x11-themes/iceicons/iceicons-0.10.0.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[desktop-wm] 
x11-themes/icewm-themes/icewm-themes-0.0.1-r1.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [desktop-wm] 
x11-themes/gdeskcal-skins/gdeskcal-skins-0.0.1.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [desktop-misc | pclouds@gentoo.org] 
Affected herds: desktop-misc, base-system, common-lisp, desktop-wm, gnustep 
Affected devs: pclouds@gentoo.org, xmerlin@gentoo.org, swtaylor@gentoo.org, 
karltk@gentoo.org, vapier@gentoo.org
Comment 16 Christian Zoffoli (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-09-02 04:36:44 UTC 
partimage* fixed.
Comment 17 Diego Elio Pettenò (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-09-15 14:49:12 UTC 
app-misc/evidence/evidence-9999.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[vapier@gentoo.org] 
dev-lisp/cmucl-source/cmucl-source-19a.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[common-lisp] 
dev-util/aegis/aegis-4.9.ebuild: chown called on root:root [karltk@gentoo.org] 
gnustep-libs/artresources/artresources-0.1.2.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[gnustep] 
mail-mta/courier/courier-0.50.1-r1.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[swtaylor@gentoo.org] 
sys-apps/baselayout/baselayout-1.12.0_pre8-r2.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [base-system | azarah@gentoo.org, agriffis@gentoo.org] 
sys-apps/sal-client/sal-client-1.0_rc3.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[base-system] 
sys-apps/man/man-1.6a.ebuild: chown called on root:root [base-system] 
x11-themes/windowmaker-themes/windowmaker-themes-0.1.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [gnustep] 
x11-themes/iceicons/iceicons-0.10.0.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[desktop-wm] 
x11-themes/icewm-themes/icewm-themes-0.0.1-r1.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [desktop-wm] 
x11-themes/gdeskcal-skins/gdeskcal-skins-0.0.1.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [desktop-misc | pclouds@gentoo.org] 
Affected herds: desktop-misc, base-system, common-lisp, desktop-wm, gnustep 
Affected devs: pclouds@gentoo.org, azarah@gentoo.org, agriffis@gentoo.org, 
swtaylor@gentoo.org, karltk@gentoo.org, vapier@gentoo.org 
 
This for 31 october, also if maybe can be finished before that date ;) 
Please :)
Comment 18 Diego Elio Pettenò (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-09-15 15:01:53 UTC 
gdeskcal-skins fixed.
Comment 19 Diego Elio Pettenò (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-10-09 14:28:10 UTC 
Current logs: 
 
dev-lisp/cmucl-source/cmucl-source-19a.ebuild: chown called on root:root  
[common-lisp]  
dev-util/aegis/aegis-4.9.ebuild: chown called on root:root [karltk@gentoo.org]  
gnustep-libs/artresources/artresources-0.1.2.ebuild: chown called on root:root  
[gnustep]  
mail-mta/courier/courier-0.50.1-r1.ebuild: chown called on root:root  
[swtaylor@gentoo.org]  
sys-apps/baselayout/baselayout-1.12.0_pre8-r2.ebuild: chown called on  
root:root [base-system | azarah@gentoo.org, agriffis@gentoo.org]  
sys-apps/sal-client/sal-client-1.0_rc3.ebuild: chown called on root:root  
[base-system]  
sys-apps/man/man-1.6a.ebuild: chown called on root:root [base-system]  
x11-themes/windowmaker-themes/windowmaker-themes-0.1.ebuild: chown called on  
root:root [gnustep]  
x11-themes/iceicons/iceicons-0.10.0.ebuild: chown called on root:root  
[desktop-wm]  
x11-themes/icewm-themes/icewm-themes-0.0.1-r1.ebuild: chown called on  
root:root [desktop-wm]  
Affected herds: base-system, common-lisp, desktop-wm, gnustep  
Affected devs: azarah@gentoo.org, agriffis@gentoo.org, swtaylor@gentoo.org,  
karltk@gentoo.org
Comment 20 Diego Elio Pettenò (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-10-25 06:10:51 UTC 
dev-lisp/cmucl-source/cmucl-source-19a.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[common-lisp] 
dev-util/aegis/aegis-4.9.ebuild: chown called on root:root [karltk@gentoo.org] 
gnustep-libs/artresources/artresources-0.1.2.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[gnustep] 
mail-mta/courier/courier-0.50.1-r1.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[swtaylor@gentoo.org] 
sys-apps/baselayout/baselayout-1.12.0_pre9-r1.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [base-system | azarah@gentoo.org, agriffis@gentoo.org] 
sys-apps/sal-client/sal-client-1.0_rc3.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[base-system] 
sys-apps/man/man-1.6a.ebuild: chown called on root:root [base-system] 
x11-themes/windowmaker-themes/windowmaker-themes-0.1.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [gnustep] 
x11-themes/iceicons/iceicons-0.10.0.ebuild: chown called on root:root 
[desktop-wm] 
x11-themes/icewm-themes/icewm-themes-0.0.1-r1.ebuild: chown called on 
root:root [desktop-wm] 
Affected herds: base-system, common-lisp, desktop-wm, gnustep 
Affected devs: azarah@gentoo.org, agriffis@gentoo.org, swtaylor@gentoo.org, 
karltk@gentoo.org
Comment 21 Diego Elio Pettenò (RETIRED) gentoo-dev 2005-12-16 05:19:03 UTC 
I've fixed all the tree but sal-client as that's also using other things that 
might not work and has a low low priority right now.