Summary: | MATE 1.18 stable request | ||
---|---|---|---|
Product: | Gentoo Linux | Reporter: | Pacho Ramos <pacho> |
Component: | Stabilization | Assignee: | Gentoo MATE Desktop <mate> |
Status: | RESOLVED FIXED | ||
Severity: | normal | CC: | leio, phmagic, stephan.litterst, tango |
Priority: | Normal | Flags: | stable-bot:
sanity-check+
|
Version: | unspecified | ||
Hardware: | All | ||
OS: | Linux | ||
See Also: | https://bugs.gentoo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=664998 | ||
Whiteboard: | |||
Package list: |
app-arch/engrampa-1.18.3 amd64 x86
app-editors/pluma-1.18.3 amd64 x86
app-text/atril-1.18.3 amd64 x86
dev-libs/libmateweather-1.18.2 amd64 x86
dev-python/python-caja-1.18.1 amd64 x86
mate-base/caja-1.18.5 amd64 x86
mate-base/libmatekbd-1.18.2 amd64 x86
mate-base/mate-1.18 amd64 x86
mate-base/mate-applets-1.18.2 amd64 x86
mate-base/mate-applets-meta-1.18 amd64 x86
mate-base/mate-common-1.18.0 amd64 x86
mate-base/mate-control-center-1.18.2 amd64 x86
mate-base/mate-desktop-1.18.0 amd64 x86
mate-base/mate-menus-1.18.1 amd64 x86
mate-base/mate-panel-1.18.7 amd64 x86
mate-base/mate-session-manager-1.18.2-r1 amd64 x86
mate-base/mate-settings-daemon-1.18.2 amd64 x86
mate-extra/caja-dropbox-1.18.0 amd64 x86
mate-extra/caja-extensions-1.18.2 amd64 x86
mate-extra/mate-calc-1.18.1 amd64 x86
mate-extra/mate-indicator-applet-1.18.1 amd64 x86
mate-extra/mate-media-1.18.2 amd64 x86
mate-extra/mate-netbook-1.18.2 amd64 x86
mate-extra/mate-polkit-1.18.2 amd64 x86
mate-extra/mate-power-manager-1.18.1 amd64 x86
mate-extra/mate-screensaver-1.18.2 amd64 x86
mate-extra/mate-sensors-applet-1.18.3 amd64 x86
mate-extra/mate-system-monitor-1.18.1 amd64 x86
mate-extra/mate-user-guide-1.18.0 amd64 x86
mate-extra/mate-user-share-1.18.0 amd64 x86
mate-extra/mate-utils-1.18.3 amd64 x86
media-gfx/eom-1.18.3 amd64 x86
media-libs/libmatemixer-1.18.0 amd64 x86
x11-misc/mate-notification-daemon-1.18.1 amd64 x86
x11-misc/mozo-1.18.0 amd64 x86
x11-terms/mate-terminal-1.18.2 amd64 x86
x11-themes/mate-backgrounds-1.18.0 amd64 x86
x11-themes/mate-icon-theme-1.18.2 amd64 x86
x11-themes/mate-icon-theme-faenza-1.18.1 amd64 x86
x11-themes/mate-themes-3.22.11 amd64 x86
x11-wm/marco-1.18.2 amd64 x86
|
Runtime testing required: | --- |
Description
Pacho Ramos
![]() How can I help to stabilize mate 1.18? Upstream declares 1.16 as stable and 1.18 unstable, and i have to agree on that, 1.18 is still buggy and have quite lot of outstanding bugs (upstream issue tracker). After discussing this with NP, we are going to follow upstream, thus stabilize 1.16 (very soon), and finally drop the old 1.12 from tree. "very soon" could be interpreted in a lot of different ways. What is *your* definition of "very soon"? (In reply to Ettore Di Giacinto from comment #2) > Upstream declares 1.16 as stable and 1.18 unstable, and i have to agree on > that, 1.18 is still buggy and have quite lot of outstanding bugs (upstream > issue tracker). After discussing this with NP, we are going to follow > upstream, thus stabilize 1.16 (very soon), and finally drop the old 1.12 > from tree. And Gentoo is lagging behind MATE 1.18, there are newer releases upstream for MATE 1.18 Looking to the blockers for Mate 1.16 stabilization (bugs solved in 1.18), I am not sure if even 1.18 considered as "unstable" would still be a better candidate than 1.16 :/ *** Bug 654806 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. *** (In reply to Pacho Ramos from comment #5) > Looking to the blockers for Mate 1.16 stabilization (bugs solved in 1.18), I > am not sure if even 1.18 considered as "unstable" would still be a better > candidate than 1.16 :/ Thu Jun 8 00:40:31 2017 >>> mate-base/mate-common-1.18.0 Thu Jun 8 00:45:20 2017 >>> x11-themes/mate-icon-theme-1.18.2 Thu Jun 8 00:46:09 2017 >>> x11-themes/mate-backgrounds-1.18.0 Thu Jun 8 00:47:39 2017 >>> mate-base/mate-desktop-1.18.0 Thu Jun 8 00:51:40 2017 >>> dev-libs/libmateweather-1.18.0 [...] ^ according to genlop I've literally used mate 1.18.x for over a year. EVERY bug 1.12.x, 1.14.x, or 1.16.x is fixed on 1.18.x (or more specifically: the ones which personally caused me problems) (In reply to Pacho Ramos from comment #5) > Looking to the blockers for Mate 1.16 stabilization (bugs solved in 1.18), I > am not sure if even 1.18 considered as "unstable" would still be a better > candidate than 1.16 :/ Second that: I would prefer 1.18 get stabilized over 1.16. Been working with 1.18 on my 2 of my workstations for a few months now and have no major issues. I will be updating to 1.18 on my other 2 systems some time this coming week as 1.12 has gotten kinda stale. Would also like to see 1.20 moved into portage for testing purposes. Lets say that this is some heavy maintainer timeout, or rather that I had OK to prep stable list for 1.18 from mudler that he can ACK then, but I'm CCing arches immediately due to not getting an automated repoman sanity check otherwise. mudler also said he knows no big issues with 1.18 over the rest and has been using it for a long time, just too busy with non-gentoo things. Lets just proceed with stabilizing please. x86 stable amd64 stable but I postponed the push till evning, but it should be fired till the end of this day. finally stable |