| Summary: | media-video/ogmrip - add support for ogg container | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Product: | Gentoo Linux | Reporter: | Arc Riley <arc> |
| Component: | Current packages | Assignee: | Gentoo Media-video project <media-video> |
| Status: | RESOLVED OBSOLETE | ||
| Severity: | normal | CC: | kripton, treecleaner |
| Priority: | Normal | Keywords: | PMASKED |
| Version: | unspecified | ||
| Hardware: | All | ||
| OS: | Linux | ||
| Whiteboard: | |||
| Package list: | Runtime testing required: | --- | |
|
Description
Arc Riley
2011-06-10 22:57:56 UTC
So where's the bug? The bug is the non-functional theora USE flag, misleading users into believing this application supports Ogg Theora. Or you could fix the ebuild to properly enable Ogg. Ubuntu 11.04's package for ogmrip 0.13.6 supports Ogg files properly and depends on oggz-tools which Gentoo's ebuild does not. Emerging liboggz alone does not enable Ogg container on Gentoo, so its more tricky than a missing dependency. (In reply to comment #2) > The bug is the non-functional theora USE flag, misleading users into believing > this application supports Ogg Theora. Container != codec, so I don't really see a problem ... There's theora (codec), or ogg (container), but not theora + ogg, right? Basically, theora codec only support. local:ogm:media-video/ogmrip: Support for OGM container format global:ogg: Adds support for the Ogg container format (commonly used by Vorbis, Theora and flac) global:theora: Adds support for the Theora Video Compression Codec ogmrip has use flags for theora, and ogm, but not ogg, so it looks fine to me. Even the description is accurate: Graphical frontend and libraries for ripping DVDs and encoding to AVI/OGM/MKV/MP4 This doesn't change that the upstream package supports Ogg Theora (ogv) and its packaged correctly for other distros, but not Gentoo. Perhaps an ogg USE flag should be added for the insane case that someone may want to use Theora in a Quicktime file. (In reply to comment #6) > This doesn't change that the upstream package supports Ogg Theora (ogv) and its > packaged correctly for other distros, but not Gentoo. "Ogg Theora" is a misnomer. Ogg is the container, Theora is the codec. > Perhaps an ogg USE flag should be added for the insane case that someone may > want to use Theora in a Quicktime file. Why would we add an ogg use flag, if we don't support the ogg container? You should add Ogg container support so that Gentoo users don't have to load up an Ubuntu virtual machine to rip a dvd to ogv. With thoggen removed from Portage and this ebuild not supporting Ogg there is no longer a DVD ripping utility on Gentoo which does this. (In reply to comment #8) > You should add Ogg container support so that Gentoo users don't have to load up > an Ubuntu virtual machine to rip a dvd to ogv. Ah, gotcha. *little light goes on* Patch the build so it has support for the container. > With thoggen removed from Portage and this ebuild not supporting Ogg there is > no longer a DVD ripping utility on Gentoo which does this. I'm not sure what Ubuntu is doing to provide that, so ... patch welcome. :) I do see this on ogmrip's site, though, so not sure if we just need the "Oggz" plugin or not. http://ogmrip.sourceforge.net/en/plugins.html Olivier, what you say? From the docs, and what I see on Ubuntu, it supports Ogg through oggz. The Ogg container is available through plugins. See https://bugs.gentoo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=336361 Package removed. |
