Summary: | net-dialup/ppp-2.4.4-r15 breaks GPRS connectivity | ||
---|---|---|---|
Product: | Gentoo Linux | Reporter: | Michael Mohr <akihana> |
Component: | Current packages | Assignee: | Gentoo Dialup Developers <net-dialup> |
Status: | RESOLVED NEEDINFO | ||
Severity: | normal | ||
Priority: | High | ||
Version: | unspecified | ||
Hardware: | x86 | ||
OS: | Linux | ||
Whiteboard: | |||
Package list: | Runtime testing required: | --- |
Description
Michael Mohr
2008-07-27 21:24:14 UTC
Here is an excerpt from messages, if it helps: Jul 27 14:00:20 cerium pppd[8756]: Plugin passwordfd.so loaded. Jul 27 14:00:20 cerium pppd[8756]: pppd 2.4.4 started by mohr, uid 0 Jul 27 14:00:20 cerium pppd[8756]: Removed stale lock on rfcomm0 (pid 7968) Jul 27 14:00:24 cerium hcid[6744]: link_key_request (sba=00:15:E9:66:9A:34, dba=00:1E:8D:ED:40:CF) Jul 27 14:00:25 cerium chat[8760]: abort on (ERROR) Jul 27 14:00:25 cerium chat[8760]: abort on (NO ANSWER) Jul 27 14:00:25 cerium chat[8760]: abort on (NO CARRIER) Jul 27 14:00:25 cerium chat[8760]: timeout set to 5 seconds Jul 27 14:00:25 cerium chat[8760]: send (ATZ^M) Jul 27 14:00:25 cerium chat[8760]: expect (OK) Jul 27 14:00:28 cerium chat[8760]: ATZ^M^M Jul 27 14:00:28 cerium chat[8760]: OK Jul 27 14:00:28 cerium chat[8760]: -- got it Jul 27 14:00:28 cerium chat[8760]: send (AT+CGDCONT=1,"IP","internet3.voicestream.com","0.0.0.0",1,1^M) Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium chat[8760]: expect (OK) Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium chat[8760]: ^M Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium chat[8760]: AT+CGDCONT=1,"IP","internet3.voicestream.com","0.0.0.0",1,1^M^M Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium chat[8760]: OK Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium chat[8760]: -- got it Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium chat[8760]: send (ATDT*99***1#^M) Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium chat[8760]: timeout set to 60 seconds Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium chat[8760]: expect (CONNECT) Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium chat[8760]: ^M Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium chat[8760]: ATDT*99***1#^M^M Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium chat[8760]: CONNECT Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium chat[8760]: -- got it Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium chat[8760]: send (^M) Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium pppd[8756]: Serial connection established. Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium pppd[8756]: Using interface ppp0 Jul 27 14:00:29 cerium pppd[8756]: Connect: ppp0 <--> /dev/rfcomm0 Jul 27 14:00:30 cerium pppd[8756]: PAP authentication succeeded Jul 27 14:00:31 cerium pppd[8756]: LCP terminated by peer (User request) Jul 27 14:00:34 cerium pppd[8756]: Connection terminated. Jul 27 14:00:35 cerium pppd[8756]: Modem hangup Jul 27 14:01:09 cerium hcid[6744]: link_key_request (sba=00:15:E9:66:9A:34, dba=00:1E:8D:ED:40:CF) Jul 27 14:01:10 cerium chat[8771]: abort on (ERROR) Jul 27 14:01:10 cerium chat[8771]: abort on (NO ANSWER) Jul 27 14:01:10 cerium chat[8771]: abort on (NO CARRIER) Jul 27 14:01:10 cerium chat[8771]: timeout set to 5 seconds Jul 27 14:01:10 cerium chat[8771]: send (ATZ^M) Jul 27 14:01:10 cerium chat[8771]: expect (OK) Jul 27 14:01:10 cerium chat[8771]: ATZ^M^M Jul 27 14:01:10 cerium chat[8771]: OK Jul 27 14:01:10 cerium chat[8771]: -- got it Jul 27 14:01:10 cerium chat[8771]: send (AT+CGDCONT=1,"IP","internet3.voicestream.com","0.0.0.0",1,1^M) Jul 27 14:01:11 cerium chat[8771]: expect (OK) I don't see how this could be a regression bug since net-dialup/ppp never had a bug like this. And scripts don't create pppX interfaces, pppd does that. If you find time to solve your problem, here is a hint: the relevant difference between r14 and r15 is the installation of modprobe.d file vs modules.d (no longer used on Gentoo). Since I'm also unwilling to work with uncooperative users, I close this bug as INVALID. Please don't label me as uncooperative. You folks are the ones who build this thing called Gentoo, and it is a great product. I don't have the time right now to debug teh problem, esp. since this laptop takes 15 minutes to recompile ppp. I entered this bug for you, so that you would be aware of a problem with your distribution. I provided a description of what went wrong with debug info from messages. If you don't want to resolve this regression bug, thats fine.. I just can't do any testing at this time, so close it again if thats how you feel. Sorry for being a good citizen and reporting regressions. 1) I find hard to believe your laptop compiles net-dialup/ppp for 15 minutes. Even a 386 box should compile it in less than 5 minutes. 2) I still don't understand why you consider this to be a regression. Regression bug == bug solved in some previous version which reappeared in the current version. Please point me to the previous bug you are referring to. 3) I cannot solve bugs that I cannot reproduce. You should at least give me a simple way to reproduce it *without* constraining me to use some particular hardware I don't have. Either that or find the solution yourself. 4) Differences between r14 and r15 have nothing to do with the alleged bug. These are the changes occured in that version: *ppp-2.4.4-r15 (12 Apr 2008) 12 Apr 2008; Alin Năstac <mrness@gentoo.org> +ppp-2.4.4-r15.ebuild: Re-write kill-pg.patch (#181145 and #216183). Fix LCP timeout error (#210852). Fix QA warning (#211160). Install modprobe.d file (#213879). I'm sorry, but since you are unwilling to investigate it further, I will close this as NEEDINFO. Please don't reopen it unless you have relevant information. |