Bug 218094

Summary:	Please remove all media-video/ffmpeg-0.4.9_p20081014 incompatible plugins.
Product:	Gentoo Linux	Reporter:	Ben de Groot (RETIRED) <yngwin>
Component:	New packages	Assignee:	Television related Applications in Gentoo's Portage <media-tv>
Status:	VERIFIED FIXED
Severity:	normal
Priority:	High
Version:	unspecified
Hardware:	All
OS:	Linux
Whiteboard:
Package list:		Runtime testing required:	---
Bug Depends on:
Bug Blocks:	214740

Description Ben de Groot (RETIRED) gentoo-dev

2008-04-17 13:01:50 UTC

FFmpeg recently changed all the include paths. Every application using it
should update. Make sure the applications build against currently hardmasked media-video/ffmpeg-0.4.9_p20080326.

media-tv herd to do:

media-plugins/mytharchive
media-plugins/vdr-audiorecorder
media-plugins/vdr-softdevice
media-plugins/vdr-softplay
media-tv/nuvexport

Comment 1 Matthias Schwarzott gentoo-dev

2008-04-21 10:57:54 UTC

FIXED:
media-plugins/vdr-audiorecorder
media-plugins/vdr-softdevice
media-plugins/vdr-softplay

Comment 2 Matthias Schwarzott gentoo-dev

2008-04-21 17:52:31 UTC

Not yet listed affected packages:
media-plugins/vdr-dxr3 [fixed now]

Not yet fixed:
media-plugins/vdr-graphtft

Comment 3 Ben de Groot (RETIRED) gentoo-dev

2008-06-22 17:31:48 UTC

vdr-graphtft fixed according to hd_brummy, so unmasked

what about mytharchive and nuvexport?

Comment 4 Samuli Suominen (RETIRED) gentoo-dev

2008-12-10 23:37:19 UTC

You have 30 days to fix your packages, ffmpeg is going stable and broken
packages will be masked by treecleaners.

Comment 5 Samuli Suominen (RETIRED) gentoo-dev

2008-12-11 10:16:24 UTC

(In reply to comment #3)
> what about mytharchive and nuvexport?

MythTV is entirely broken and won't compile due to multiple different bugs.
It's required to test the packages. This won't be stopping us.

Comment 6 Doug Goldstein (RETIRED) gentoo-dev

2008-12-11 18:39:06 UTC

MythTV isn't entire broken... MythTV works perfectly fine for me and a lot of other users thank you very much. It even works great for upstream developers using Gentoo. In fact our MythTV packages work so good that it's one of the more popular platforms for using MythTV.

Comment 7 Samuli Suominen (RETIRED) gentoo-dev

2008-12-13 08:43:26 UTC

Then test nuvexport (or remove it, as beandog said) and test stable mytharchive or get it stabilized. Old version will be masked for removal regardless with
the old ffmpeg revisions when we are done.

Comment 8 Samuli Suominen (RETIRED) gentoo-dev

2008-12-15 19:22:11 UTC

Since you reopened this, I guess we can use this one. Please remove all plugins that doesn't compile against =media-video/ffmpeg-0.4.9_p20081014, since we need
to package.mask old version soon due to open CVEs. Open stable bugs where needed, remove unused versions where needed, .. you get the drift.

media-plugins/mytharchive-0.20.2_p14807
media-plugins/mytharchive-0.20.2_p14877
media-plugins/mytharchive-0.21_p17105
media-plugins/mytharchive-0.21_p17948
media-plugins/mytharchive-0.21_p18355
media-plugins/vdr-audiorecorder-0.1.0_pre6
media-plugins/vdr-dxr3-0.2.8
media-plugins/vdr-graphtft-0.1.18_alpha
media-plugins/vdr-graphtft-0.1.21_alpha
media-plugins/vdr-image-0.2.7-r1
media-plugins/vdr-image-0.2.7.26
media-plugins/vdr-osdpip-0.0.10
media-plugins/vdr-osdpip-0.0.8-r1
media-plugins/vdr-osdpip-0.0.8-r2
media-plugins/vdr-osdpip-0.0.9
media-plugins/vdr-pcd-0.9
media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.4.0
media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.4.0.20070711
media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.4.0.20070711-r1
media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.4.0.20080120
media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.5.0
media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.5.0-r1
media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.5.0.20080922
media-plugins/vdr-softplay-0.0.2.20060815
media-plugins/vdr-softplay-0.0.2.20070730
media-plugins/vdr-softplay-0.0.2.20080421
media-tv/nuvexport (do we need this package? does it work?)

Comment 9 Samuli Suominen (RETIRED) gentoo-dev

2008-12-15 19:53:51 UTC

(In reply to comment #8)
> Since you reopened this, I guess we can use this one. Please remove all plugins
> that doesn't compile against =media-video/ffmpeg-0.4.9_p20081014, since we need
> to package.mask old version soon due to open CVEs. Open stable bugs where
> needed, remove unused versions where needed, .. you get the drift.
> 
> media-plugins/mytharchive-0.20.2_p14807
> media-plugins/mytharchive-0.20.2_p14877
> media-plugins/mytharchive-0.21_p17105
> media-plugins/mytharchive-0.21_p17948
> media-plugins/mytharchive-0.21_p18355

Cardoe told me on IRC these are calling ffmpeg from system() and should be compatible with the mentioned ffmpeg versions.

> media-plugins/vdr-audiorecorder-0.1.0_pre6
> media-plugins/vdr-dxr3-0.2.8
> media-plugins/vdr-graphtft-0.1.18_alpha
> media-plugins/vdr-graphtft-0.1.21_alpha
> media-plugins/vdr-image-0.2.7-r1
> media-plugins/vdr-image-0.2.7.26
> media-plugins/vdr-osdpip-0.0.10
> media-plugins/vdr-osdpip-0.0.8-r1
> media-plugins/vdr-osdpip-0.0.8-r2
> media-plugins/vdr-osdpip-0.0.9
> media-plugins/vdr-pcd-0.9
> media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.4.0
> media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.4.0.20070711
> media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.4.0.20070711-r1
> media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.4.0.20080120
> media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.5.0
> media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.5.0-r1
> media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.5.0.20080922
> media-plugins/vdr-softplay-0.0.2.20060815
> media-plugins/vdr-softplay-0.0.2.20070730
> media-plugins/vdr-softplay-0.0.2.20080421

What about these? Can't test them myself.

> media-tv/nuvexport (do we need this package? does it work?)

Cardoe told me on IRC this is a perl script..

Comment 10 Samuli Suominen (RETIRED) gentoo-dev

2008-12-17 06:58:48 UTC

> media-plugins/vdr-audiorecorder-0.1.0_pre6
> media-plugins/vdr-dxr3-0.2.8
> media-plugins/vdr-graphtft-0.1.18_alpha
> media-plugins/vdr-graphtft-0.1.21_alpha
> media-plugins/vdr-image-0.2.7-r1
> media-plugins/vdr-image-0.2.7.26
> media-plugins/vdr-osdpip-0.0.10
> media-plugins/vdr-osdpip-0.0.8-r1
> media-plugins/vdr-osdpip-0.0.8-r2
> media-plugins/vdr-osdpip-0.0.9
> media-plugins/vdr-pcd-0.9
> media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.4.0
> media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.4.0.20070711
> media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.4.0.20070711-r1
> media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.4.0.20080120
> media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.5.0
> media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.5.0-r1
> media-plugins/vdr-softdevice-0.5.0.20080922
> media-plugins/vdr-softplay-0.0.2.20060815
> media-plugins/vdr-softplay-0.0.2.20070730
> media-plugins/vdr-softplay-0.0.2.20080421

Cleaned up everything that didn't compile and/or link against -lswscale properly. This bug should be fixed now, thank you for the non-cooperation from vdr the maintainers.

Thanks Cardoe for providing the answers :)