Bugzilla Bug 10730

i think it should be a big problem to integrate the atmel wlan driver into
gentoo as already done for the linux-wlan-ng project. The only thing that should
be done is to make a ebuild which manages to compile the driver against the
gentoo sources (the compile clean - I've already tryied it).

i meant: it shouldn't be a big problem - not it should be! Type Error - forgive
me ;-)

please create an ebuild and attach it here

http://atmelwlandriver.sourceforge.net/

Does anybody have one of these?

Created an attachment (id=30859) [details]
two submitted ebuilds

(From update of attachment 30859 [details])
see my comment to bug

The ebuilds just submitted (file atmel-ebuilds.tgz; 2004-05-06) are based on
the following considerations:

1) kernel modules for ATMEL wlan cards are available from sourceforge as noted
previously, but are also included in kernel 2.6. 

2) The modules included with kernel 2.6 lack the necessary firmware to operate
the cards (at least for the on I have).

3) Both module packages seem to lack some capability for scanning site access
points, for example, with gtkskan. However, the sourceforge package contains a
special command line utility that works for these drivers and cards.

I have, therefore, written ebuilds for both:

atmlwlandriver-3.2.4.4: This is the latest version of the drivers available
from sourceforge. This, together with kernel 2.6.5, is currently the only
combination that works for my PCMCIA card in a satisfactory way. But there are
several problems left. Kernel 2.6 refuses to load the PCI driver of this
package. The USB drivers aren't working either because I don't know the
appropriate USB configuration. Also, I don't have either PCI or USB hardware to
test. The package should work for kernel 2.4, but I can't test that because I
am experiencing problems with the PCMCIA core under kernel 2.4.25

atmel-firmware-0.7: This ebuild incorporates a firmware package that
complements the atmel drivers included with kernel 2.6. On my machine,
everything works nicely (card is recognized, driver is loaded, correct firmware
is loaded, LED on card lights up...) until you actually want to attach to an
access point.... I don't think that this problem is related to the ebuild.
Either, there is a bug in the driver or the firmware, or else, I am making some
stupid mistake in using the iw* tools.

The sourceforge driver looks pretty messy and may not have a long life. On the
other hand, the kernel 2.6-driver doesn't seem to be quite up to par, yet. In
any case, I hope that either or both ebuilds may be of some help to others.

Well, there is already a 3.3.5.6 version out...

Any plans to update the ebuilds? I tried but the patches are too big and Makefile is quite changed anyway. Now they support 2.6 series as well.

Will anybody finally include this in the source tree so it can get some more user testing?

> Does anybody have one of these?

I have no experience in *writing* ebuilds, but I have not one but *two* affected devices connected to my Gentoo boxes (SMC 2632W-V2 PCMCIA, Belkin F5D6050 USB) and would be willing to give an updated ebuild some field testing.

Is there still initerest in adding this driver-ebuild?
(will you test it when I write a new ebuild?)

I have recently tested this package, and it did not work any longer (it
complains about sandbox violations). However the atmel-firmware package from
Bug #52893, together with the in-kernel atmel driver works flawlessly.

Created an attachment (id=49579) [details]
atmelwlandriver-3.4.1.0.ebuild

Working (at least compiling) ebuild, please test and comment

Is this really worth it? The 2.6 kernel contains an atmel driver, that works if
 the atmel-firmware package is installed. AFAIK Gentoo 2005.0 will ship with
2.6 kernel as the default.

However I don't know if there are any cases where the atmelwlandriver works
better than the in-kernel version.

On the other hand, the driver is not in 2.4, so it might be of use to those
that do not wish to upgrade kernel.

then we will stick to the in-kernel version.

I will close this as WONTFIX