Gentoo Full Text Bug Listing

Description:

Opened: 2006-10-26 08:24 0000

While attempting to install the latest stable (on SPARC) kernel
(gentoo-sources-2.6.17-r8) on a Netra X1 I ran into the following problem.

Whenever I attempt to boot over the network I receive one of the error messages
listed below:

IDPROM: Warning, unknown format type!
Illegal Instruction
Memory Address not Aligned
Data Access Exception
Fast Instruction Access MMU Miss

The error message can be changed by compiling a random kernel component in or
out to change the size of the generated kernel.  All kernels I have tried have
been less than 3MB, some less than 2.5MB.

I then tried installing every available version of gentoo-sources back to
2.6.14-r7 with the same result.  At this point I moved to testing
vanilla-sources, unfortunately with no improvement.  

Kernel versions 2.6.13-r5 and earlier all boot fine.  This led me to believe
that the issue was probably introduced in 2.6.14.  After scanning through the
changelog for that version I have found the following commit:

commit bff06d552240ba7f5b49482a4865871d7bc03dc2
Author: David S. Miller
Date:   Thu Sep 22 20:11:33 2005 -0700

    [SPARC64]: Rewrite bootup sequence.

    Instead of all of this cpu-specific code to remap the kernel
    to the correct location, use portable firmware calls to do
    this instead.

    Signed-off-by: David S. Miller

Seems like more than a coincidence to me...  

After much searching of the web I have found that the following architectures
are affected:

Sun Netra X1 (UltraSPARC-IIe 400MHz)
Sun Fire V240
Sun Blade 2500

Using OBP versions 4.0.5, 4.3.2, 4.5.9 and 4.17.1.

Should I file this directly with the kernel maintainers?

------- Comment #2 From Gustavo Zacarias (RETIRED) 2006-11-07 11:21:54 0000 -------

One of the sparc devels has a V240 running with recent kernels just fine.
However this isn't related since the X1 is a completely different machine. And
unfortunately we lack an X1 to help so it's best if you try upstream with the
sparclinux mailing list.

------- Comment #4 From Gustavo Zacarias (RETIRED) 2006-12-26 07:02:22 0000 -------

We're happy if you're happy.
2.6.19-r2 won't go stable until we work around the qlogic firmware issue that
2.6.18+ got (removed firmware from the kernel, thus blade 1000/2000 machines
can't boot from builtin disk).
Though it's a genkernel issue and completely unrelated.

Bug#: 152882	Product: Gentoo Linux	Version: unspecified	Platform: Sparc64
OS/Version: Linux	Status: CLOSED	Severity: major	Priority: P2
Resolution: UPSTREAM	Assigned To: sparc@gentoo.org	Reported By: max.gentoo.bugzilla@hacking.co.uk
Component: Core system
URL:
Summary: kernel >= 2.6.14 won't boot on Netra X1
Keywords:
Status Whiteboard:
Opened: 2006-10-26 08:24 0000