110572 2005-10-26 14:07 0000 app-laptop/i8kutils - i8k init.d script fails to daemonize i8kmon 2006-10-01 17:59:42 0000 1 1 1 Unclassified Gentoo Linux Applications unspecified All Linux RESOLVED FIXED P2 normal --- 1 xenos@xenos-1.net tester@gentoo.org sebroeder@gmail.com toby.smithe@gmail.com xenos@xenos-1.net 2005-10-26 14:07:33 0000 When the /etc/init.d/i8k script runs to start i8kbuttons and i8kmon, i8kmon fails to load. Reproducible: Always Steps to Reproduce: 1.emerge i8kutils 2./etc/init.d/i8k start Actual Results: * Starting i8kbuttons ... [ ok ] * Starting i8kmon ... [ !! ] Expected Results: * Starting i8kbuttons ... [ ok ] * Starting i8kmon ... [ ok ] The solution seems simple enough. Could someone implement it? 30,31c30,31 < --make-pidfile --exec /usr/bin/i8kmon --background \ < -- -d ${NOAUTO:+-na} ${TIMEOUT:+-t $TIMEOUT} --- > --make-pidfile --exec /usr/bin/tclsh --background \ > -- /usr/bin/i8kmon -d ${NOAUTO:+-na} ${TIMEOUT:+-t $TIMEOUT} xenos@xenos-1.net 2005-10-26 14:11:01 0000 (In reply to comment #0) > When the /etc/init.d/i8k script runs to start i8kbuttons and i8kmon, i8kmon > fails to load. > > Reproducible: Always > Steps to Reproduce: > 1.emerge i8kutils > 2./etc/init.d/i8k start > > Actual Results: > * Starting i8kbuttons ... > [ ok ] > * Starting i8kmon ... > [ !! ] > > > Expected Results: > * Starting i8kbuttons ... > [ ok ] > * Starting i8kmon ... > [ ok ] > > > The solution seems simple enough. Could someone implement it? > > 30,31c30,31 > < --make-pidfile --exec /usr/bin/i8kmon --background \ > < -- -d ${NOAUTO:+-na} ${TIMEOUT:+-t $TIMEOUT} > --- > > --make-pidfile --exec /usr/bin/tclsh --background \ > > -- /usr/bin/i8kmon -d ${NOAUTO:+-na} ${TIMEOUT:+-t $TIMEOUT} sorry, that's the diff between the broken /etc/init.d/i8k script and my working version. Conor xenos@xenos-1.net 2005-11-22 15:29:19 0000 (In reply to comment #0) > When the /etc/init.d/i8k script runs to start i8kbuttons and i8kmon, i8kmon > fails to load. > Reproducible: Always > Steps to Reproduce: > 1.emerge i8kutils > 2./etc/init.d/i8k start > Actual Results: > * Starting i8kbuttons ... > [ ok ] > * Starting i8kmon ... > [ !! ] > Expected Results: > * Starting i8kbuttons ... > [ ok ] > * Starting i8kmon ... > [ ok ] > The solution seems simple enough. Could someone implement it? > 30,31c30,31 > < --make-pidfile --exec /usr/bin/i8kmon --background \ > < -- -d ${NOAUTO:+-na} ${TIMEOUT:+-t $TIMEOUT} > --- > > --make-pidfile --exec /usr/bin/tclsh --background \ > > -- /usr/bin/i8kmon -d ${NOAUTO:+-na} ${TIMEOUT:+-t $TIMEOUT} I would like to see this little problem fixed. What is involved in becoming a package maintainer? Who do I need to speak with? It's not like this is a huge bug. azote@slinux.net 2005-12-17 19:23:49 0000 (In reply to comment #2) this last one works for me .... tester@gentoo.org 2006-01-05 20:39:14 0000 taking over this package. I'll try to look at this problem this weekend xenos@xenos-1.net 2006-01-06 04:11:24 0000 (In reply to comment #4) > taking over this package. I'll try to look at this problem this weekend > Awesome! Thank you. sebroeder@gmail.com 2006-01-09 14:12:00 0000 The tclsh patch works for me too, but I realized that the modified init script needs tcl to be installed (wiped it out incidently by emerge -depclean). So we should add a tcl dependency to the ebuild or find another approach to solve the pid problem. Regards, Sebastian tester@gentoo.org 2006-01-15 09:13:33 0000 strange, the current script seems to work fine here. Are you usin i8kutils 1.25? Which version of baselayout ? sebroeder@gmail.com 2006-04-19 07:37:07 0000 I use the ~x86 baselayout (1.23.0_pre17-r2). Not sure if it works atm, have to sort some things out first. Strange however is that /usr/bin/i8kmon is not installed anymore by the ebuild. Is this intended? toby.smithe@gmail.com 2006-09-01 06:45:12 0000 OK. It's not installed any more by default as it depends on the USE flag "tk", as it can be run in a GUI mode. I am surprised that it hasn't been fixed yet, with such a simple patch to be applied. xenos@xenos-1.net 2006-09-08 04:26:36 0000 (In reply to comment #7) > strange, the current script seems to work fine here. > Are you usin i8kutils 1.25? Which version of baselayout ? > I'm using the following: # emerge -p baselayout i8kutils These are the packages that would be merged, in order: Calculating dependencies... done! [ebuild R ] sys-apps/baselayout-1.12.4-r6 [ebuild R ] app-laptop/i8kutils-1.25 To this day I still have to modify the init script to get i8kmon to daemonize. rogerx@sdf.lonestar.org 2006-09-26 19:48:11 0000 Can we please add an einfo (or echo) at the end of the package build stating, "i8kmon will only be built if the tk flag is enabled. Without i8kmon, the daemon will not be able to control the fans (with /etc/i8kmon.conf)"? Or, maybe have /etc/init.d/i8k* notify in syslog "i8kmon was not found, rebuild i8kutils with the tk to build this binary"? rogerx@sdf.lonestar.org 2006-09-27 04:00:44 0000 I have fixed the i8kmon within /etc/init.d/i8kmon. Before, it would always fail starting because the i8kmon bin file forks to a tclsh process and does not truely run in the background. ebegin "Starting i8kmon" start-stop-daemon -b --start --quiet --name "tclsh /usr/bin/i8kmon" \ --exec /usr/bin/i8kmon \ -- -d ${NOAUTO:+-na} ${TIMEOUT:+-t $TIMEOUT} eend $? 1) For some reason, "--background" was not fully working. So I switched to the short term "-b" and moved it forward in the start-stop-daemon function. 2) Used "--name" to check for the process name instead. I belive I can do --name "tclsh i8kmon" to more accurately filter /proc names, as you can see, i've implemented it within the stop function ebegin "Stopping i8kmon" start-stop-daemon --stop --quiet --name "tclsh /usr/bin/i8kmon" eend $? 1) Again, I removed the make-pid stuff as, again, i8kmon forks to another process and I am just checking for the simple name of "tclsh /usr/bin/i8kmon". Ok. retested. Ask if you want a diff. tester@gentoo.org 2006-10-01 17:59:42 0000 after a long long time.. I've applied the fixes from comment #12