Bugzilla Bug 44816

sys-devel/automake-1.7.7/RDEPEND:     >=sys-devel/autoconf-2.57 
sys-apps/acl-2.2.13-r1/RDEPEND:       sys-devel/autoconf 
sys-libs/gpm-1.20.1/RDEPEND:  sys-devel/autoconf 
app-editors/emacs-21.3-r2/RDEPEND:    >=sys-devel/autoconf-2.58 
sys-fs/xfsprogs-2.3.9/RDEPEND:        sys-devel/autoconf
media-libs/alsa-lib-0.9.8/RDEPEND:    >=sys-devel/autoconf-2.57-r1
media-libs/hermes-1.3.2-r2/RDEPEND:   sys-devel/autoconf 
media-libs/a52dec-0.7.4/RDEPEND:>=sys-devel/autoconf-2.52d-r1 
dev-util/strace-4.4.98/RDEPEND:       >=sys-devel/autoconf-2.54 
app-misc/screen-4.0.1-r2/RDEPEND:     >=sys-devel/autoconf-2.57 
kde-base/kdelibs-3.2.1/RDEPEND:>=sys-devel/autoconf-2.58
games-strategy/freeciv-1.14.1/RDEPEND:        >=sys-devel/autoconf-2.13


dev-libs/libmcrypt-2.5.7/RDEPEND:>=sys-devel/automake-1.6.1
net-misc/ntp-4.1.2/RDEPEND:   >=sys-devel/automake-1.7
media-libs/alsa-lib-0.9.8/RDEPEND:    >=sys-devel/automake-1.7.2
media-libs/hermes-1.3.2-r2/RDEPEND:   sys-devel/automake
app-admin/metalog-0.8_pre20031130/RDEPEND:    sys-devel/automake 
app-text/sgml-common-0.6.3-r3/RDEPEND:>=sys-devel/automake-1.6 
games-strategy/freeciv-1.14.1/RDEPEND:        >=sys-devel/automake-1.4

the only thing that looks "correct" here is the sys-devel/automake RDEPEND on
autoconf

i dont know where you got the freeciv or ntp matches because they're def not
like that in cvs

i fixed xfsprogs, strace, screen and libmcrypt cause i was bored :p

fixed app-editors/emacs and app-text/sgml-common

Well, This could be for any revision in the cvs, as my tests don't track
changes in packages that don't change revisions.  Inherent design decision

*** Bug 44815 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

media-* fixed

SpanKY, if you're feeling bored, feel free to take on some sound bugs...

I think your detection tool may need to be revised as it missed a package
(which I've fixed)...  ogmtools had:

DEPEND="dvd? ( media-libs/libdvdread )
        >=sys-devel/automake-1.6.0
        media-sound/vorbis-tools"

with no RDEPEND, so RDEPEND was implicitly containing
>=sys-devel/automake-1.6.0

Actually it only worked on a subset from one of my old-time passive installs. 
I should rework it to something that uses portageq and works against the
/usr/portage tree.

any new list ?

ahh sorry, I did get one but there was all too many false positives (Even more)
due to eclass'es  which I didn't handle.  :-/   

Created an attachment (id=28351) [edit]
list packages which RDEPEND on autoconf

Created an attachment (id=28352) [edit]
list of packages which RDEPEND on automake

hmm, what code are you using to generate this list?  *curious*

I'm greping the portage cache.

oh. that simple.. now I feel foolish. *wry grin*   *looks at his long lines of
logics duplicating ebuild.sh and other things*

Is it worth bugging aliz to include a hit list (sed, automake, make, awk,
grep,...) that will fail if they are implicit RDEPENDS and list these packages
with a QA fault on http://gentoo.tamperd.net/stable? Or likewise implementing
it in repoman?

Other questions while I remember:
Can as a general rule with QA bug can you attach grep and the like code as it
probably will help.
Is there a reason http://gentoo.tamperd.net/stable isn't hosted on an official
domain?

I think it would be good to have this info on g.t.n/s ... I think it doesn't
really need to be in repoman, though...

mr_bones: could you attach an updated list?

Created an attachment (id=36040) [edit]
list packages which RDEPEND on autoconf

Created an attachment (id=36041) [edit]
list of packages which RDEPEND on automake

grep -nr 'sys-devel/automake' --exclude "*pickle" /var/cache/edb/dep/ | egrep
':[2]:' | sed 's:/var/cache/edb/dep/::; s/:[2]:/:/' | sed 's/:.*//' >
/tmp/automake.rdepend

There's the command I used.

Why don't ya do libtool too, while you're at it?

Created an attachment (id=36042) [edit]
list of packages which RDEPEND on libtool

All of sound's packages are fixed.

could you please update the list ?

SpanKY, You still need updated lists? In comment#20,  |sed 's:usr/portage/::' 
is missing. Though I don't know why only the second lines of edb-files might be
relevant, a line like this might be what You need:

for package in automake autoconf libtool; do
  grep -nr "sys-devel/$package" --exclude="*pickle" \
      /path/to/gentoo/var/cache/edb/dep/ \
  | awk '/:2:/ {print
gensub(".*/var/cache/edb/dep/(usr/portage/)?([^:]*):2:.*", "\\2", 1, $0);} \
  > /tmp/rdepends_on_$package
done

BTW: quite troublesome to get a backslash typed with german keymapping, I used
"echo '' | od -t c" to get a "\n" printed and restarted gpm with "-2" to work
around the missing middle butten... :-)

ups - sorry, cut-n-paste errors:
 - the trailing `` ' 

ups - sorry, cut-n-paste errors:
 - the trailing `` ' ´´ was missing
 - that "awk" line must be one line - my inputfield broke it into two lines.

for package in automake autoconf libtool; do
  grep -nr "sys-devel/$package" --exclude="*pickle" $ROOT/var/cache/edb/dep/ \
  | awk '/:2:/ {print \
gensub(".*/var/cache/edb/dep/(usr/portage/)?([^:]*):2:.*", "\\2", 1, $0);}' \
  > /tmp/rdepends_on_$package
done

As of these lines, only three bind-ebuilds are still having dependencies on
autoconf:
net-dns/bind-9.3.1-r8
net-dns/bind-9.2.5-r10
net-dns/bind-9.3.2_beta2-r2

Feedback wanted: were these the lines that You needed?
Then this bug might be closed real soon. :-)

Nothing left here, if anything else RDEPENDs on autoconf & co. implicitely,
that's because it needs explicit RDEPEND (Bug 142755) due to eclass
inheritance.

Closing.