On my system I have a global "alsa -oss" setting (at /etc/make.conf). It doesn't matter right now if that's wrong or right, but the fact is this setting is in there for years and years. However, since libmikmod does not support alsa, removing oss makes it compile support only for raw files, which gives some troubles, like bug 99590. Even though the last comment on that bug is from December 2005, people continue to hit that bug even later than that (such as bug 97507 comment 13, which is from December 2009, just a few months ago). Thus, I suggest a simple small addition. Add a BIG FAT WARNING at the libmikmod ebuild, suggesting that "-oss" is probably not what the user wants. This way, at least people will know what's wrong and how to fix it (I could only discover that because I read the libmikmod ebuild source). Such warning could also be added to sdl-mixer ebuild, if libmikmod[-oss] is detected. Another solution is to check for alsa useflag, and build oss support if either alsa or oss is enabled. That means that "alsa -oss" will build support for oss. Although strange, oss is the only way to make libmikmod work with alsa, and thus such behavior make some sense. Finally, yet another solution is to replace "oss" useflag by "no-oss", which should only be enabled if the user really knows what he's doing.
I've already added USE="raw" to the libmikmod ebuild which should disable this behavior, no "music.raw" file is written anymore...
(In reply to comment #1) > I've already added USE="raw" to the libmikmod ebuild which should disable this > behavior, no "music.raw" file is written anymore... I've just tested running the gweled game. With the stable libmikmod-3.2.0_beta2-r1, it creates a music.raw. With the non-stable libmikmod-3.2.0_beta2-r2, it creates a music.wav. The -r1 had "-oss", and the -r2 had "-oss -raw". Everything on a recent (synched earlier today) and stable amd64. The only way to make gweled play music and NOT fill my HD with worthless file was to enable "oss" in libmikmod.
(In reply to comment #1) > I've already added USE="raw" to the libmikmod ebuild which should disable this > behavior, no "music.raw" file is written anymore... And, by the way, the build log shows this: Drivers to be compiled: raw wav aiff pipe stdout nosound So I guess the patch could have fixed this ./configure output, so it doesn't write misleading info. ;)
+ 12 Mar 2010; Samuli Suominen <ssuominen@gentoo.org> + libmikmod-3.1.12.ebuild, libmikmod-3.2.0_beta2-r2.ebuild: + Warn users if USE="oss" is disabled wrt #308919. The only other modification will be when someone offers a working alsa patch. *** This bug has been marked as a duplicate of bug 97507 ***
