Bugzilla Bug 176297

There're still a number of annoying minor, sometimes longstading, issues, but
overall it's quite bearable. I propose targeting stabilization of KDE 3.5.6 in
four weeks from now. That allows enough testing of the latest kdelibs revision
and leaves some time to look at other bugs.

sounds good to me.  I think 3.5.7 will be out by then too.

only one dependent bug? ;)

What about bug 177035 ? That one bugs me on 3.5.6-r1 even with USE=debug ...

(In reply to comment #2)
> only one dependent bug? ;)

A lot more, but I won't start adding them before next week.



Guys, please stop using this tracker asking for your pet bugs. Bug 169289 isn't
relevant for stabilization and no I don't intend to do anything about bug
177035. We don't have enough human ressources and seems not to be a regression
to 3.5.5. Vote on the upstream bug or have a look at the code yourself. A patch
is welcome.

o.k., staring a bit earlier

Bug 163853 is a dependecy of this one.

We're way behind our schedule so stabilising 3.5.6 doesn't really make sense
anymore. Thus, we're recycling this bug for the stabilisation of KDE 3.5.7.

Bug 163853 is still a dependecy of this one, I think :P

Added a few more dependencies. (Yes, 163853 is in, too. :-) )

Maybe Bug 178693 should be removed from depend list:
>=www-misc/htdig-3.2.0_beta6-r2 is stable in every arch except mips. However,
KDE-3.5.7 isn't going to be stable in mips, because it isn't keyworded in that
arch (see kdebase as an example).

So now Bug 178693 doesn't block this anymore and should be removed.

Created an attachment (id=126887) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-everything-package.keywords.txt

Created an attachment (id=126888) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-monolithic-alpha.txt

Created an attachment (id=126890) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-monolithic-amd64.txt

Created an attachment (id=126892) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-monolithic-hppa.txt

Created an attachment (id=126893) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-monolithic-ia64.txt

Created an attachment (id=126894) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-monolithic-ppc64.txt

Created an attachment (id=126896) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-monolithic-ppc.txt

Created an attachment (id=126897) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-monolithic-sparc.txt

Created an attachment (id=126898) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-monolithic-x86.txt

Created an attachment (id=126899) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-split_and_meta-alpha.txt

Created an attachment (id=126901) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-split_and_meta-amd64.txt

Created an attachment (id=126902) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-split_and_meta-ia64.txt

Created an attachment (id=126904) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-split_and_meta-ppc64.txt

Created an attachment (id=126905) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-split_and_meta-ppc.txt

Created an attachment (id=126907) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-split_and_meta-sparc.txt

Created an attachment (id=126909) [edit]
kde-3.5.7-split_and_meta-x86.txt

Ok, I've now attached the stabilisation lists.
kde-3.5.7-everything-package.keywords.txt is a complete arch-agnostic list in
package.keywords format. The other lists are arch-specific and for both the
monolithic and the split/meta packages. All (unless I've missed something :) )
deps (including expat and aspell) are included for your convenience as they
have to be done together anyway. :)

Should I have missed a newer revision, please stabilise that. Be sure to
stabilise this stuff together with the blockers of this bug, please. Please
raise question or concerns here or bug me on IRC in #gentoo-kde.

Arches will be cc'ed later this night when the Gnome herd has finished their
final polishing. Don't be surprised if either a KDE herd or the Gnome herd
member CCs the arches on the other one's bug respectively. This is perfectly
fine as discussed between leio and myself. After all, we're all working on free
desktops!

Arches, please go for it! Please take note of comment #27.

You should commit the stabilisation as much as possible at the same time as the
stabilisations in bug 187730 (expat-2.0.1), bug 187731 (curl-7.6.14 and pycurl)
and bug 185823 (GNOME-2.18), bug 178690 (aspell and its dicts) for maximum user
convenience, because the expat and curl new versions break ABI and many GNOME
and KDE packages - by doing it at the same time the user doesn't need to
recompile so much, as he/she can do the upgrade and recompile at the same time
then.

At least these are missing 
kde-base/qtjava-3.5.7 amd64 ppc ppc64 x86
kde-base/smoke-3.5.6 amd64 ppc ppc64 sparc x86
kde-base/qtruby-3.5.7 amd64 ppc ppc64 sparc x86
kde-base/korundum-3.5.7 amd64 ppc ppc64 sparc x86
kde-base/dcopperl-3.5.6-r1 amd64 ppc ppc64 sparc x86
kde-base/dcoppython-3.5.7 amd64 ppc ppc64 sparc x86
kde-base/kjsembed-3.5.7 alpha amd64 ia64 ppc ppc64 sparc x86
kde-base/kdejava-3.5.7 amd64 ppc ppc64 x86
kde-base/kdebindings-meta-3.5.7 amd64 ppc ppc64 x86

Is that ok, KDE team?  Current stable of above pulls in kdelibs-3.5.5 and makes
Portage bail out...

(In reply to comment #29)
> kde-base/qtjava-3.5.7 amd64 ppc ppc64 x86
> kde-base/smoke-3.5.6 amd64 ppc ppc64 sparc x86
> kde-base/qtruby-3.5.7 amd64 ppc ppc64 sparc x86
> kde-base/korundum-3.5.7 amd64 ppc ppc64 sparc x86
> kde-base/dcopperl-3.5.6-r1 amd64 ppc ppc64 sparc x86
> kde-base/dcoppython-3.5.7 amd64 ppc ppc64 sparc x86
> kde-base/kjsembed-3.5.7 alpha amd64 ia64 ppc ppc64 sparc x86
> kde-base/kdejava-3.5.7 amd64 ppc ppc64 x86
> kde-base/kdebindings-meta-3.5.7 amd64 ppc ppc64 x86
> 
> Is that ok, KDE team?  Current stable of above pulls in kdelibs-3.5.5 and makes
> Portage bail out...

Christian and other arch teams, please stabilise the above packages, too.
(Which are, apart from dcopperl, all included in the "everything"-list.) Sorry
for missing them in the first place in the individual lists. 

sparc stable with the added bonus of kdesdk & kdesdk-meta.

Marked ppc stable.

alpha/ia64 stable, i hope i didn't left anything out

ppc64 stable

amd64 stable

At least these two packages are missing in the amd64 stabilization:

kde-base/kdesdk-kfile-plugins
kde-base/kompare

Please, add amd64 to the CC list.

*** Bug 188447 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

(In reply to comment #36)
> kde-base/kdesdk-kfile-plugins
> kde-base/kompare

kde-base/kdesdk-kioslaves-3.5.7
kde-base/kcachegrind-3.5.7 (Bug 188429)

 (In reply to comment #38)
> (In reply to comment #36)
> > kde-base/kdesdk-kfile-plugins
> > kde-base/kompare
> kde-base/kdesdk-kioslaves-3.5.7
> kde-base/kcachegrind-3.5.7 (Bug 188429)

In fact, kdesdk and kdesdk-meta had not been stabilised by amd64. I've now done
that. :-)

I'm still missing kde-base/cervisia-3.5.7 and kde-base/kdesdk-meta-3.5.7 on
amd64.

Additionally the following kde-base/*-3.5.7 packages seems to be missing on all
arches:
=kde-base/artsplugin-mpeglib-3.5.7
=kde-base/kdat-3.5.7
=kde-base/kpackage-3.5.7
=kde-base/kpilot-3.5.7
=kde-base/ksysv-3.5.7
=kde-base/kuiviewer-3.5.7
=kde-base/pykde-3.5.7

(In reply to comment #40)
> Additionally the following kde-base/*-3.5.7 packages seems to be missing on all
> arches:
> =kde-base/artsplugin-mpeglib-3.5.7
> =kde-base/kdat-3.5.7
> =kde-base/kpackage-3.5.7
> =kde-base/kpilot-3.5.7
> =kde-base/ksysv-3.5.7
> =kde-base/kuiviewer-3.5.7
> =kde-base/pykde-3.5.7

CCing everyone back. 

ppc64 stable

Please note that kde-base/kpilot-3.5.7 is masked and does NOT go stable.

alpha/ia64/x86 stable, i guess.

Feel free to readd if i missed something :)

All marked stable on amd64 apart from =kde-base/pykde-3.5.7 which won't compile
here with dev-python/PyQt-3.14.1-r1 (and dev-python/PyQt-3.14.1-r2 is marked
-amd64). Bringing in python@g.o in the hope that they'll be able to help.

Philantrop, the reason PyQt-3.14.1-r2 is marked -amd64 is because of bug
#155170.
That bug can easily be resolved by applying the patch in comment #42.

Apart from that, I'll look into testing pykde in a few days...

kpilot-3.5.7 sparc stable.
kuiviewer-3.5.7 and kdat-3.5.7 were already stable.
pykde, artsplugin-mpeglib, kpackage and ksysv don't have ~sparc keywords.

Stable for HPPA.

stable on ppc, except for kpilot.

Thanks, guys, we're done here for now. The remaining issues (pykde, kpilot)
will be dealt with in their respective individual bugs.