Bugzilla Bug 105188

Hi,
I thought I had found a bug in mv according to contradictions to what it is said
in its man page, but after asking in the mail list[1] it seems that gentoo is
shipping a mv man page not corresponding to the mv program that it's shipped.

Explanation:
Older versions of mv came in the fileutils package, but last versions came in
the coreutils packages. Gentoo is shipping last mv from coreutils package but
old man page from deprecated fileutils package.

Reproduceability:
Coreutils install man pages for the binaries it provides, but as you see this is
not the case for the mv man page:

gnelson man # equery files sys-apps/coreutils | grep mv
/bin/mv
/usr/bin/mv -> /bin/mv
gnelson man #

Instead the mv man page is located in the man-pages ebuild:

gnelson man # equery files sys-apps/man-pages | grep mv
/usr/share/man/man1/mv.1.gz
/usr/share/man/man1p/mv.1p.gz
gnelson man #


Solution:
Install man pages that comes in coreutils package[2] and delete the deprecated
ones that are in man-pages ebuild. Apart from mv I think other coreutils
binaries like cp has the same problem.

[1] http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/bug-coreutils/2005-08/msg00078.html
[2] http://www.gnu.org/software/coreutils/

Reproducible: Always
Steps to Reproduce:

not really, we use the manpage from the man-pages package, not from coreutils

I also see this problem with "ls".  In fact, the date at the bottom of the ls
man page is "1998-11", and the page is missing some options (the one I was
looking for was --time-style).

If you look on FC5 or Ubuntu, the man pages are from coreutils and are much
more up-to-date and match the command better.  Also, since "ls" is part of
coreutils, it does indeed seem wrong not to include the coreutils man pages for
the applicable commands.

I suggest somethine be done to at least get more relevant man pages or Gentoo,
which I love, looks a bit stale when it comes to some of the man pages.

I would also like to kindly request Gentoo to use the coreutils manpages
instead of the (very) outdated man-pages package. It is annoying to have to
login to a Fedora machine and read the manpages there, to find out what the
commandline options are. Gentoo supports the same commandline options, but
they're "undocumented" because the manpages are obsolete. New uptodate manpages
exist, I would very much appreciate it if they could be used instead.

*** Bug 158985 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

OK, I'll try better search before posting bug...
Anyway, I modified ebuilds for man-pages and coreutils to resolve this problem.
See there:
https://bugs.gentoo.org/attachment.cgi?id=104674 (coreutils)
https://bugs.gentoo.org/attachment.cgi?id=104675 (man-pages)

Sigh; why are we still installing the horribly obsolete stuff? :/

i find this rather annoying as well. is there a specific reason for not
providing the man pages to the programs we actually use?

fixed in coreutils-6.9-r1

*** Bug 177826 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***

sorry for the duplicate bug report. i should search with prefix 'ALL' before
reporting new bugs :(